Ismail Patel writes in Middle East Eye on 30 September 2025:
The 20-point “peace plan” presented by US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was hailed by Trump as a momentous step toward “eternal peace in the Middle East”.
While some Arab leaders, including the Palestine Mission in the UK, have welcomed it, an analysis of the proposal shows it is fundamentally harmful to Palestinians.
It is characterised by profound asymmetry, conditional rights, and the imposition of external control, reflecting a continuation of colonialist logic rather than a genuine pathway to self-determination.
Trump, in the shoes of previous imperialists, imposed the plan as an ultimatum.
The plan was unveiled during a joint press conference with Trump and Netanyahu, without any Palestinian representatives in attendance. This approach is reminiscent of the imperial tactics used by the British with the Balfour Declaration in 1917 and the UN in 1947, when the partition of Palestine was imposed without consulting the Palestinian people.
The plan is inherently asymmetrical. It demands that Hamas, which was not invited to negotiate the terms, accept the conditions or face the threat of Israel “finishing the job”. While the present proposal asks Hamas to surrender its weapons, it essentially means that all future Palestinians relinquish their right to self-defence, in effect surrendering Palestinian security to the Israelis.
This demand, coupled with the insistence that Hamas and other factions have no role in Gaza’s governance, amounts to a call for political submission and disarmament in exchange for acknowledging Israeli colonisation.
A colonialist plan
A central pillar of the colonialist nature of the plan is its systematic erosion of the Palestinian right to self-determination, primarily through conditional statehood and perpetual external oversight.
The plan offers no guarantee for the creation of a Palestinian state.