In the West, Jewish voices are embracing anti-Zionism. Palestinians must seize this moment


With Israel's top global sponsor in decline, dramatic shifts in public opinion are taking place across the western world

Awad Abdelfattah writes in Middle East Eye on 12 November 2026:

The publication of Benjamin Moser’s Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History comes at a significant political moment.

Alongside the growing anti-genocide movement in the West, and the British Green Party’s recent adoption of a motion supporting a single democratic state in historic Palestine, the book helps to bring a question once marginalised in mainstream western debate into sharper focus: is Zionism an inseparable expression of Jewish identity, or a political ideology that must itself be challenged?

Moser, an American Jewish writer and Pulitzer Prize-winning biographer, approaches this question by recovering a largely suppressed tradition of Jewish opposition to Zionism.  Through portraits of 12 Jewish figures, including Hannah Arendt, Edwin Montagu, Felicia Langer and Avi Shlaim, he demonstrates that opposition to Zionism is neither new nor alien to Jewish intellectual and political history.

The importance of his intervention goes beyond the historical recovery of individual voices. It challenges one of Zionism’s most powerful political claims: that Jewish identity, collective security and national existence necessarily require a state organised around Jewish privilege in Palestine.  Moser’s work helps to establish that Jewish identity and opposition to Zionism are not contradictory, and that Jewish political and ethical traditions have also produced alternatives to exclusive nationalism.

This is particularly relevant after the genocide and destruction of Gaza, which have exposed the consequences of a political system founded on Palestinian dispossession, ethnic cleansing and the denial of Palestinian national rights.

Questioning Zionism
The growing willingness of Jewish intellectuals, activists and public figures to question Zionism has contributed to a wider shift in western political discourse.

The British Greens’ decision reflects this changing atmosphere. So does the mobilisation of Americans, Palestinians, Muslims, Jewish anti-Zionists, students, trade unionists and ordinary citizens who have challenged their governments’ military and political support for Israel.

What began, for many, as opposition to the destruction of Gaza has increasingly developed into a broader questioning of the structures of occupation, apartheid and settler-colonialism. Israel has become one of the most widely condemned countries in the world, and its founding myths are increasingly collapsing.  Yet an important distinction remains. Not everyone who opposes Israel’s actions supports anti-Zionism, and not everyone questioning Zionism has embraced the vision of one democratic state.

Nevertheless, the boundaries of political debate are changing. The question is no longer confined to how Palestinians might obtain a state alongside Israel, but increasingly concerns the legitimacy of the colonial Zionist project and the political framework that governs the entire territory, from the river to the sea.

Here lies an uncomfortable paradox for the Palestinian national movement. While sections of the western left are beginning to challenge Zionism as a political framework, much of the Palestinian leadership continues to negotiate within that framework, seeking a Palestinian state alongside Israel through a partition formula that has become increasingly detached from the realities on the ground.

This is not simply an intellectual disagreement. It concerns the future of the Palestinian liberation struggle.

International recognition of Palestinian statehood remains important and should not be dismissed. But recognition cannot be a substitute for the exercise of national rights, nor can it resolve questions about refugees, equality, dispossession and the fragmentation of the Palestinian people.

More ….

© Copyright JFJFP 2026