Dare to imagine the end of Jewish supremacy


We are constantly told that it is 'either us or them,' that this is a zero-sum game. And so, imagining a different future here is made exceedingly difficult. Difficult, but possible. Difficult, but necessary

Hagai El-Ad writes in Haaretz on 19 November 2026:

Israel’s neo-Kahanist discourse prides itself on a semantic evolution from “Death to the Arabs” – an expression of overt racism that was simply too blatant – to “Death to the terrorists”: the latter supposedly nonracist, certainly legitimate in Israel, and even enshrined in a law (“Death Penalty for Terrorists Law, 5786–2026”) passed by the outgoing Knesset.

The problem is that if all “Arabs” are presumed to be “terrorists,” the bottom line is the same: death to them all. And just how much is it the same? It turns out that this goes well beyond the claim that “there are no uninvolved civilians in Gaza.” It encompasses the entire Palestinian spectrum, including Palestinian citizens of the State of Israel.

After all, this is the logical meaning of the cry following the October 27 Israeli elections, of “ballot-box terrorism”: an Arab citizen who casts a vote is committing an act of terror. Anyone who commits an act of terror is a terrorist. A terrorist deserves death. Death to terrorists = Death to Arabs. Q.E.D..

The idea that anything a Palestinian does amounts to terrorism is hardly new, of course. Israel has long labeled demonstrations “popular terrorism,” calls for sanctions “economic terrorism,” appeals to international institutions “diplomatic terrorism,” and so on.

At the root of this is the position that Palestinians must not resist Israeli actions in any way whatsoever. Palestinians are expected to meekly accept their displacement (across the globe), their killing (in Gaza), their dispossession (in the West Bank), and their status as third-class “permanent residents” (in East Jerusalem) or second-class citizens (inside Israel).  They must not resist. They are not entitled to self-defense. Any form of resistance is terrorism.

Yet a Palestinian citizen of Israel’s decision to go out and vote in the Knesset election carries the potential to undermine this logic, simply because it holds out the possibility of being counted like every other vote – no more and no less.

In other words, at least for the moment when the envelope containing the ballot is placed in the box, it offers the possibility of not being second-class, if only for a fleeting instant. In that sense, the very act of voting is an expression of resistance to Jewish supremacy. Palestinian resistance? That, of course, is terrorism. Ballot-box terror.

The potential to cease being second-class is severely limited, of course, by Israel’s system of government, as enshrined in legislation (including Basic Laws), court rulings and policy.

Not only because, to begin with, only a minority of Palestinians under Israeli rule are citizens and therefore eligible to vote in elections, but because no Palestinian citizen of Israel needs the words written here to know all too well how Israel was established and how, since 1948, practices of Jewish supremacy have become entrenched in every sphere of life. Jewish supremacy is the default.

It is how Israel breathes, the very condition of existence here, requiring no effort at all. Making things otherwise would require an enormous effort.

And yet: the possibility that things could be different. That fleeting moment at the ballot box. Do not let that thought slip away.  This possibility may be one of the most optimistic thoughts imaginable. By contrast, it is clear that there are many Israelis who are terrified by it, who abhor it and vehemently oppose it.

And yet, in a fleeting moment of optimism (the kind that inspires dread in many others), one can also imagine the entire house of cards of Jewish supremacy collapsing.

If a Palestinian citizen inside Israel ceases to be a second-class citizen and begins to be treated as a person with equal rights, then one can imagine, on the distant horizon, a logic that eventually encompasses the entire Palestinian spectrum. For a fleeting moment, one can imagine a future in which everyone is human.

This is precisely what leads people like Shin Bet chief David Zini – and many other Israelis – to instinctively identify broad participation by Palestinian citizens in Israel’s electoral process with “political subversion” and a challenge to “the foundations of the regime.”

After all, the system of government is based on Jewish supremacy, and anything that challenges it is considered subversive – and therefore a matter for the Shin Bet.

Subversion? As new Likud lawmaker Yaakov Bardugo explained on pro-Netanyahu Channel 14, it is “a direct continuation of October 7 … much more than terrorism.”

But it is not terrorism. It is “an act of self-defense,” as veteran Joint List lawmaker Dr. Ahmad Tibi put it. It is “the most powerful nonviolent tool or instrument in a democratic society,” in the words of the late John Lewis, one of the leaders of the American civil rights movement.

Nearly 20 years ago, Prof. Amnon Raz-Krakotzkin wrote about Israel as a “state of six months.” He was referring to a fleeting period, “less than one percent of the time Israel has existed”: the six months between the abolition of military rule over Palestinian citizens in December 1966 and the beginning of the occupation in June 1967, when there was a state here that did not impose military rule on any Palestinians.

We have become so accustomed to such a reality, on both sides of the Green Line separating Israel and the West Bank, that it is difficult to imagine a turning point at which the processes of the past 100 years – ever more land coming under Jewish control alongside the contraction of Palestinian existence into increasingly smaller areas – come to a halt.

We are constantly told that it is either us or them, that this is a zero-sum game, that a government “with those who seek to destroy the State of Israel” would amount to “national suicide,” as Prime Minister Netanyahu claims. And so,imagining a different future here is made exceedingly difficult.

Difficult, but possible. Difficult, but necessary. Just as Palestinian journalist Abed Abu Shahadeh recently said in his hometown of Jaffa, shortly after his release from detention and Shin Bet questioning: “Now, in these days, we need to talk about a better future. Because between the river and the sea there are both Jews and Arabs, and we need to learn to live together.

“We must offer an alternative. Our path is the right one, a path based on equality for all. We must keep going. We must not stop. We must not be afraid.”

This article is reproduced in its entirety

© Copyright JFJFP 2026