The Gaza war is over, but not for the world’s artists and academics


To the extent that Israeli business faced a boycott, it's over. Not so at the universities and in the arts, and soft power is too important for Israel to ignore A flooded street in Khan Yunis, Gaza, following heavy rain, 11 December 2025

David Rosenberg writes in Haaretz on 11 December 2025:

It must have come as something of a shock to many Israelis when four countries announced last week that they would be boycotting the Eurovision Song Contest this year in protest against Israel’s war in Gaza. They were even joined by a fifth country on Wednesday, and a sixth may follow.

For Israelis, the war is over, and however brutal the fighting was, they are ready to move on. There is a struggle underway over how the debacle of October 7 should be investigated, and the army has conducted two of its own probes, but almost no one is talking about examining how the army fought the war itself. It’s history that should be left to the historians one day to examine, not a thing to be grappled with in the here and now.

But the Gaza war remains very much alive in many places outside Israel. As Ireland’s RTÉ said in a statement announcing its decision to pull out of Eurovision, “Ireland’s participation remains unconscionable given the appalling loss of lives in Gaza and the humanitarian crisis there, which continues to put the lives of so many civilians at risk. RTÉ remains deeply concerned by the targeted killing of journalists in Gaza during the conflict.”

This is not the only post-war BDS event. At the end of October, more than two weeks after the cease-fire, more than 1,000 literary figures, including authors Sally Rooney, Arundhati Roy and Rachel Kushner, signed a pledge to boycott Israeli cultural institutions. A global initiative to ban music from Israel called No Music for Genocide that was launched in September is still signing up artists and labels. Likewise, a campaign called Filmmakers for Palestine had its pledge to boycott Israel signed by stars like Emma Stone.

Nor has the boycott by European institutions of higher education against Israel eased, according to a report released last month by Israel’s Association of University Heads. Even if the wave of publicly declared boycotts has ebbed, in many cases, Israeli academics continue to face hidden boycotts in the form of papers rejected by journals and non-invitations to academic conferences.

It’s safe to assume that a lot of these BDS drives, which began in the heat of the war, will quietly fade away if the cease-fire holds. No organizer will ever put out a statement saying a celebrity has unsigned a pledge, but many of these promises to isolate Israel will gradually be forgotten. Nevertheless, Israel can’t count on a clean break from the stain of the war.

As the continued BDS initiatives demonstrate, in the worlds of culture and academics, Israel remains a persona non grata. Opposition to a brutal war over the course of the past two years often morphed into opposition to Israel’s existence as a Jewish state. Hostility to Israel has become an integral part of the progressive agenda, one that is shared by many artists and academics. The impact of the war has been too big for a mere cease-fire to reverse that.

However, that isn’t the entire BDS story.

Businesses and most governments were, at best, reluctant supporters of efforts to isolate Israel during the war, and since the cease-fire went into force in October, have been anxious to drop the issue entirely.Note how the business end of Hollywood, the studios, publicly rejected the Filmmakers for Palestine boycott shortly after the cease-fire went into force.

Oddly, the most obvious place where the boycott is dead and buried is arms sales. Israel lost some key arms deals during the war, but since the cease-fire, Elbit Systems has signed a $2.3 billion contract with an unnamed buyer; Rafael Advanced Defense Systems has reached a similarly sized deal with Germany; and Israel Aerospace Industries is close to an agreement with Greece worth a reported 3 billion euros ($3.5 billion). IAI is also establishing a joint venture drone production plant in Morocco.

You would think that buying Israeli arms after the war would be the last thing governments would want to risk. But whatever moral stink was attached to Israeli weaponry from its war conduct is easily overcome by the twin threats facing Europe – on the one side, the growing threat from Russia; on the other, the hostility of Trump’s America to the continent’s democracies that is leaving them to fend for themselves militarily.

It’s not just in arms where business seems to be back to usual. The alleged business boycott of Israel during the war was never serious enough to show up in figures on foreign investment and trade. Indeed, the biggest cross-border merger and acquisitions deals happened while the fighting was raging, namelyPalo Alto Networks’ $25 billion purchase of CyberArk and Alphabet’s $32 billion purchase of Wiz.

Many had told about lost contracts and delays in signing them, but that seems to have ended as well. Since the cease-fire, there have been a clutch of smaller deals, such as the $625 million sale of the Israeli-American startup Carbyine to the U.S. public safety technology firm Axon. There are no recent figures on overseas investment into Israel, but those on foreign investment in tech companies showed no decline in the first nine months of this year.

Israel’s merchandise exports have edged lower this year, but oddly enough, that’s almost all due to collapsing exports to Ireland. Ireland is famously hostile to Israel, but that is unlikely to be the reason for the drop: Nearly all of Israel’s exports to the country are high-tech products and services sold to the big multinational tech firms with subsidiaries there. Far from being BDS advocates, they have fought Ireland’s efforts to impose trade sanctions on Israel.

Eye of the beholder
Given the choice of having to live with a business boycott or an arts and academic one, Israelis would almost certainly opt for the latter. Being economically isolated means the loss of exports, jobs and investment, the result being lower economic growth. The Israeli economy is far too globalized and economically advanced, and the country far too small a market, to be anything less than fully engaged with the wider world.

But no one should discount the cost of the decline in Israel’s soft power, that is, its ability to influence other countries through its culture, political values and foreign policies.

BDS supporters had a point when they called last month for a performance in Paris by the Israel Philharmonic to be cancelled because it is “an orchestra in the service of Zionist propaganda.” The claim is overstated. The Philharmonic is not an arm of the Israeli government, but a virtuoso performance by it does remind people that the country isn’t just about war and the oppression of Palestinians. Concerts almost certainly do more good for Israel’s image than the government’s ham-fisted hasbara.

In any case, culture does have a direct impact on the economy. Even if not on the scale of high-tech or natural gas, it is an export industry and creates jobs. Academic boycotts also harm the economy because they make it harder for Israeli scientists to collaborate with their peers around the world and access foreign funding that enables the kind of innovation that drives Israeli high-tech. Indeed, cross-border partnerships are so critical that without them, Israel is at risk of further brain-drain.

Don’t expect Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government to address this problem. It loathes the cultural establishment and the universities equally for their belonging to the anti-government camp and would never dream of sacrificing its war on them for the national interest. “The Sea,” a film about a Palestinian boy trying to make his way to the shore despite the obstacles placed by the government, is in contention for an Oscar this year, but Culture Minister Miki Zohar wants to punish the film industry for producing it.

This article is reproduced in its entirety

© Copyright JFJFP 2026