As Hamas and Islamic Jihad decry Trump plan, many Gazans say ‘anything is better than bloodshed’


Donald Trump's new cease-fire plan for Gaza was cautiously embraced by the Palestinian Authority, while Hamas and Islamic Jihad say the deal favors Israel. Palestinians who are living through Israel's brutal war in Gaza say they welcome 'any deal that will end the suffering' and urge Palestinians abroad not to oppose it Children waiting to receive food from a charity kitchen in Gaza’s Nuseirat refugee camp on 30 September 2025

Nagham Zbeedat writes in Haaretz on 30 September 2025:

After nearly two years of war, many Palestinians in Gaza say they want the fighting to end at almost any cost – even if that means Hamas loses power – while political factions remain divided over the U.S. President Donald Trump’s proposal to halt the war.

While residents describe living through relentless bombardment, displacement and food shortages, their overriding demand is for the violence to stop. “Frankly, the proposal is very bad, but it is better than nothing. Anything is better than the bloodshed,” one displaced father sheltering in Khan Yunis told Haaretz.

Yet among Palestinian leaders, reactions to the White House plan have been fractured: Islamic Jihad rejected it as an American-Israeli dictate, Hamas offered mixed signals and the Palestinian Authority cautiously endorsed Washington’s mediation.

Ziad Nakhaleh, Secretary-General of the Islamic Jihad Movement in Palestine, denounced the proposal as “an American–Israeli agreement that fully reflects Israel’s position and a recipe for continued aggression against the Palestinian people.” He warned that Israel was “trying, through the United States, to impose what it could not achieve by war,” calling the announcement “a recipe for igniting the region.”

Hamas, meanwhile, struck a more ambivalent tone. According to a foreign diplomat who spoke off-the-record with Haaretz, Qatari and Egyptian mediators presented the plan to Hamas’ negotiating team in Doha on Monday, and the group said it would examine the proposal “in good faith.”  In Gaza, Hamas’ Media Office director Ismail al-Thawabta dismissed the initiative outright, saying it “does not represent a real, objective or fair solution.” In a post on X, al-Thawabta argued that any proposal treating Gaza as “a security entity without sovereignty, under international administration” was “completely rejected by the collective Palestinian national consciousness.”

By contrast, the Palestinian Authority welcomed the American initiative. In a statement published by Wafa, its official news agency, the PA described Trump’s plan as “sincere and determined,” and said it “renews its joint commitment to work with the United States, regional states and partners” to end the war, secure humanitarian aid and ensure the release of hostages and prisoners.

‘Self-righteousness is easy’
Palestinian voices in Gaza and online were overwhelmingly negative about the plan, mixing anger at the terms with fear that it would mean the end of Gaza’s sovereignty forever. Still, some believe it is bad for Hamas – but not for the people of Gaza.

On X, Palestinian activist Kareem Jouda called the proposal “humiliating and degrading for Hamas,” saying it “crowns Israel’s victory,” turns Gaza into “a multinational real-estate piece,” and tests the Palestinian Authority. But Jouda, a Gazan who opposes Hamas, went on to say that “the withdrawal of Hamas from the political and military scene does not mean a defeat for the Palestinian people, nor a surrender as some may say, because the Palestinian people were never partners in creating this chaos in the first place.”

Al Jazeera Journalist Muna Omari, writing from Doha, dismissed the White House presentation as theatrical and self-serving. “Everything that came in this press conference – items, ultimatums, and threats to Hamas … is clowning around,” she wrote, arguing the initiative is not a genuine cease-fire but “a foundational reservation for the new Middle East” engineered by Washington and Tel Aviv.

Several hard-line, Hamas affiliated Gaza-based analysts framed the plan as an existential threat. Bilal Nizar Ryan (son of assassinated Hamas leader Nizar Ryan) warned that “accepting the ‘Trump’ plan means political suicide that will destroy the Palestinian cause – its present and future – starting in Gaza and ending with Israeli control over the entire region.”

He suggested recent attempts to target Hamas leaders abroad, like the attempted assassinations in Doha, were meant to prepare a replacement leadership ready to implement such an agreement, and called the proposal a “humiliating suicidal surrender plot.”

Mohammed Abdel-Aziz al-Rantisi, son of a Hamas co-founder assassinated by Israel in 2004, summarized the plan bluntly: “In short, Trump’s plan is the replacement of the Zionist occupation army with an Arab-Zionist army to uproot Hamas from their perspective. … If it were up to me, I would reject it openly and publicly.”

Taken together, these online reactions capture a mix of exhaustion and defiance on the ground: many Gazans want the fighting to stop, some see any path that secures an immediate halt as worth considering, but a strong current of opinion fears the plan would trade an end to the bombs for a loss of sovereignty and political self-determination.

However, the majority of people in Gaza urged pragmatism – and called on Hamas to accept the deal to spare lives. Khalil Sayegh, a Palestinian political analyst based in Washington with family in Gaza, wrote on X: “The plan is bad, but rejecting it is worse – and therefore, it must be accepted. Period.”  Sayegh, co-founder of the Agora Initiative, an organization that promotes reconciliation and long-term solutions for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, added, “anyone who objects to it and claims to be pro-Palestine, I want you to imagine for a second that your family has been trapped in this genocide for the past two years. Idealism and self-righteousness are easy – until it’s your family being slaughtered for no reason and no goal.”

‘I’m a parent – not a politician’
Dr. Izz Eddin Shaheen, a physician at Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital in Deir al-Balah, also criticized opponents of compromise in two posts. “All of these people, without exception – those who reject every deal because it doesn’t meet their unrealistic ambitions – have left Gaza to the massacre for two years, and are willing to leave it to slaughter for the rest of its life.” He added: “Anyone who expected an end different from what we live now either watched a different war or does not understand how the world works.”

Ghassan, a displaced father from Gaza City now in Khan Yunis, voiced desperate calls for the end of war during an interview with Haaretz. He acknowledged the skepticism some see in the plan, but he wishes for the war to end at “any cost.”

“I no longer care about plans or politics. I’m a parent – not a politician – and all I want is for my kids to live.” Like many in the Strip, Ghassan fears the references to “disarming” and “temporary administration” are just ways to control Gaza and silence its voices. However, for him, the real concern is ensuring his children live in peace. “If the plan can bring this, then welcome. But if it’s just another political game, it’s a waste of time,” he said.

In response to those voicing opposition to the Gaza plan, Ghassan says, “as long as they have not lived out in the streets, without shelter or tent, if they have not lost any family members during this war, and did not experience what it is to be displaced and not knowing where to feed your children from – they don’t get to oppose any deal that will end our suffering.”

This article is reproduced in its entirety

© Copyright JFJFP 2026