‘A lesson’ or an unjustifiable act? How Gazans see Hamas’ public killings of rivals


Who are Gaza's armed gangs are being targeted in a wave of Hamas executions, and why many Palestinians won't condemn it A Hamas militant standing guard in Gaza City as Red Cross vehicles transport the bodies of Israeli hostages back to Israeli forces, October 2025

Nagham Zbeedat reports in Haaretz on 21 October 2025:

A video that surfaced online on October 13 appears to show Hamas fighters carrying out public executions in Gaza, targeting members of local clans and armed groups. The footage shows several men forced to kneel before a crowd. Masked gunmen – some wearing green headbands associated with Hamas’ military wing – then open fire, executing the men on the spot.

The incident followed reports of a shootout earlier that morning between Hamas forces and local armed groups described by residents as “criminals or collaborators.” The video was verified by multiple news organizations as having taken place in the Sabra neighborhood of Gaza City, although the identities or affiliations of the executed men have not been confirmed.

According to sources affiliated with Hamas, the operation aimed to “restore order” and reassert the movement’s control after days of violent clashes and growing instability inside Gaza. Others, however, explain that Hamas is trying to intimidate the population and demonstrate its authority before the potential arrival of an Arab or international monitoring force, as promised by U.S. President Donald Trump’s cease-fire plan.

IDF sources have told Haaretz in recent days that soldiers can see from observation posts that armed Hamas members are shooting at Palestinians – but they have been instructed not to intervene in order to comply with the cease-fire’s vague terms.

The Trump administration’s 20-point Gaza plan pledged to disarm and replace Hamas with an interim, internationally backed technocratic administration tasked with restoring order and overseeing reconstruction. So far, however, these commitments have remained largely declarative.

Since the cease-fire went into effect on October 10, no disarmament or replacement of Hamas’ governing structures has taken place. The International Stabilization Force that Trump’s plan tasked with maintaining security in the Strip is still being formed and is not expected to deploy until the IDF has withdrawn and Hamas has been disarmed; The Guardian has reported that Egypt is expected to lead the force.

Throughout the war, there have been recurring reports of armed confrontations between Hamas and other groups in the Gaza Strip. In June, Hamas killed at least 50 members of a Palestinian gang it claimed was armed and supported by Israel. The gang, led by clan chief Yasser Abu Shabab, accused Hamas of killing “over 50 of our volunteers” as they were “guarding aid convoys and redistributing supplies that were otherwise destined for corrupt entities linked to Hamas.”

Abu Shabab, a member of a large Bedouin family in the southern Gaza city of Rafah, is known as a powerful and well-connected figure in the Strip. Sources in Gaza told Haaretz that he previously served prison sentences in Hamas-run jails for criminal offenses. At the end of last year, amid a surge in looting of humanitarian aid in southern Gaza, Abu Shabab and his men were widely accused of being behind the theft.

Such confrontations are not new. In November last year, a Hamas-run security unit known as Sahm, part of the Interior Ministry, killed at least 20 gang members who allegedly attempted to loot humanitarian aid trucks during an operation in eastern Khan Yunis and Rafah.

Troublemakers, extremists, collaborators
In Gaza’s shattered neighborhoods and towns, word of new executions spread faster than the smoke still rising from recent airstrikes. Some residents said justice had finally caught up with the “armed gangs that terrorized civilians during the war”; others whispered that Hamas was sending a warning to its enemies. “What is terrifying is that they were from us, from the people,” said one resident about the executed men.

Who are Hamas’ enemies? “These are extended families – powerful clans, in terms of business or their relations with whoever is in power,” said Majid, 36, a father of two originally from Gaza City’s Shujaiyeh neighborhood who fled to southern Gaza a few months ago.

Among the most influential is the Doghmosh family, based in the Sabra area of Gaza City where the latest executions took place. The Doghmosh family have long had a fraught relationship with Hamas, and some of their members have been linked to extremist factions such as the Army of Islam, a small organization that is affiliated with al-Qaeda and led by Mumtaz Doghmosh (who has not been seen or heard from in years).

Another video that circulated social media purportedly shows Hamas militants firing at Doghmosh family properties in Sabra. Similar clashes have been reported in previous years with other families, including the Hellis clan, led by Rami Hellis, often described locally as “troublemakers.”

“Over the two years of war, these families have looted and destroyed our lives,” said Majid. “They worked with the occupation, killed some of the best men we have in our community, and were responsible for our starvation – they were suffocating us more than the Israeli army.”

As aid is slowly getting inside the Strip, families are afraid that looters will steal the aid and resell for skyrocketing prices. “It’s about showing control, showing everyone what happens if you think of betraying your homeland,” he said. “The best thing they did was carry out the executions in public, so everyone takes it as a lesson.”  He paused before continuing: “Even people who aren’t with Hamas generally agree with this kind of thing, because in the end, those men harmed everyone, those with Hamas and those who oppose them. … Just because someone disagrees with Hamas doesn’t mean they should collaborate with Israel.”

Farouq, 25, is from Gaza City and evacuated to Deir al-Balah earlier this year and has lost around 10 kilograms in recent months due to food shortages. He expresses anger towards the gangs, and unapologetic support for the executions: “I support killing them, whether publicly or secretly.”  His statement underscores the widespread acceptance of harsh measures among some Gazans, reflecting the intense pressures and fear people face during the war. He told Haaretz that these armed militants are not “just thieves or swindlers or outlaws” but the “ringleaders of sedition,” a charge he said carries religious weight.

“In Islam,” he argued, “sedition is worse than killing; the killer is killed, so what about those who promote sedition?” He stressed that his view is not political – he saw it as a religious issue.

‘A very dangerous stage’
In addition to the Doghmosh family, the Hellis clan and the Abu Shabab gang, other groups that have clashed with Hamas in recent months include the Al-Majayda clan in Khan Yunis and the Jundiya clan. The latter, led by Ahmed Jundiya, formed an alliance earlier this year against Hamas with the Hellis clan in Gaza City’s Shujaiyeh neighborhood.

Farouq accused these armed families and groups of stealing aid, assaulting displaced people and deliberately sowing fear to impose control. He said most Gazans see them as “saboteurs who deserve punishment.”

“The territory is at a very dangerous stage,” he added. “It’s either full control or total chaos. You can’t just detain a collaborator and ask them to promise not to do it again, there’s no room to take risks.” He also warned that rhetoric from abroad can fuel internal violence by portraying Gazans as the source of the destruction, making the situation even more volatile.

Raghad, 29, a mother from Khan Yunis, shared a personal story of what she describes as deliberate sabotage. Her brother, who works at the Ministry of Health in Gaza City’s Shujaiyeh neighborhood, was ordered to transport medicines to the south before roads were shut. “They coordinated the transfer with the Israeli army,” Raghad said. But when they went to deliver the supplies, armed men linked to the Abu Shabab gang intercepted them. “They seized their phones and belongings, took the medical supplies, dumped the medicines in the street and then let them go,” she recalled.  “These actions are meant to undermine our unity and spread fear among residents,” Raghad added. “This is just one of many stories of people being kidnapped or shot.”

In the wake of such incidents, the Doghmosh family issued an official statement last week via their central council’s Facebook account, clarifying their stance amid reports of violence involving armed families.  The statement emphasized the family’s “longstanding sacrifices for the Palestinian cause” and rejected any association with individual acts of violence. It read in part: “…the elders and leaders of the Doghmosh family affirm that the family is not responsible, directly or indirectly, for any individual actions or events that do not represent us and do not reflect our positions.”

The statement also rejected “any use of our family’s name in conflicts or actions that harm the unity of our people or deviate from the national cause. The Doghmosh family remains committed to national principles, stands by our just cause and supports every effort that preserves unity and protects Palestinian lives.”

Some Palestinians see the public executions as a chilling signal from Hamas: a choice between submission or death. One of the most vocal critics is Dr. Mahmoud al‑Habbash, was born in Gaza and was a Hamas member before moving to Ramallah and joining Fatah. Al-Habbash is the Palestinian Authority’s top Sharia judge and President Mahmoud Abbas’s religious adviser; he used his Facebook page to denounce the field executions and the recent attacks on families.

Al‑Habbash wrote that the message being sent to grieving Gazans is stark: “Either we rule you as we please, or we kill you as we please.” He condemned the assault on the Doghmosh family in Gaza City and the summary executions that followed, calling the killings illegal and morally indefensible.

He singled out the case of Hisham al‑Saftawi, a Fatah member who, Al‑Habbash said, was shot by Hamas members on Saturday, “simply because he opposed the movement’s policies,” even though two of his sons were killed in the Israeli offensive. “All the language of condemnation is not enough to describe these un‑national, unethical and unlawful crimes,” Al‑Habbash wrote, warning that those who commit such injustices will face consequences.

A member of the Doghmosh family took to Facebook to defend the family’s name and recount their suffering under both Israeli attacks and Hamas operations.     Shoruq Doghmosh wrote that months ago, “Hamas considered the Doghmosh among the resisting families whose elders refused to cooperate with the occupation in exchange for staying in their neighborhoods.” Despite repeated Israeli attacks “and dozens of massacres, most members of the family stayed in Gaza City until the last day of the siege. More than 700 of them were killed, and their homes and belongings were destroyed.”

She stressed that while “individuals in any family may have acted outside the law,” this does not give Hamas the right to “storm their homes, break into their compounds in ambulances and attack people in their destroyed houses, killing women, children and young men with cold-blooded precision.” She wrote, “nothing justifies what Hamas did to the Doghmosh family,” adding, “they have no religion, and our blood is not the same as theirs.”

This article is reproduced in its entirety

 

© Copyright JFJFP 2026