Show trials for the October 7 terrorists won’t be justice. Quite the opposite


Detainees in the Sde Teiman facility.

Tal Steiner writes in Haaretz on 23 October 2025:

The Knesset Constitution Law and Justice Committee on Wednesday [22 October] discussed a draft bill proposed by MKs Simcha Rothman and Yulia Malinovsky to establish “a special court to judge the October 7 participants,” which had been approved in a preliminary hearing in the summer. The draft bill calls for establishing a special tribunal subject to political control whereby ministers, rather than the State of Israel’s independent judicial system, will determine the prosecution policy and appoint its judges.

According to the proposal, the tribunal will be allowed to deviate from the laws of evidence and the criminal law regulations, so that it will be able to convict on the basis of unacceptable materials or invalidly attained confessions. In addition, it will judge according to the genocide law, which opens the possibility of imposing a death sentence on those convicted, an unusual step for Israeli democracy, which opposes the basic values of the rule of law and human rights.

The draft bill is another chapter in an ongoing attempt by the government to replace the professional judicial system with political mechanisms subordinate to it. The draft bill, hidden under the cloak of “justice for the victims of the massacre,” is a dangerous attempt to bypass the independent judicial system and to replace it with a propaganda mechanism.

This is a direct danger to Israeli democracy that will also undermine the country’s international status. A “special tribunal” whereby politicians will decide who will be tried and will choose judges based on political considerations, while the rules of evidence are being trampled, is not an institution of justice but a governmental tool aimed at demonstrating power. It’s a direct continuation of the same trend that was evident during the judicial overhaul attempt: dismantling judicial independence and replacing it with a system controlled by the government, which is authorized to rule in capital cases.

The new draft bill doesn’t stand alone. It joins a series of initiatives attempting to expand the extent of the death penalty in Israeli law. Some are wrapped in the rhetoric of “justice for the victims,” others are meant to defend the “redemption of the Jewish people in its land” and all are designed to establish the government’s total punitive authority while erasing the boundaries of law and morality.

The same government that was unable to prevent the massacre or manage the war now wants to blur its failures by demonstrating authority over the remaining Palestinian prisoners, who are still being held without trial. In the same way the government treated them throughout the war – by means of systematic torture, humiliating prison conditions and institutionalized violence – it’s now trying to turn them into a symbol of fictitious absolute power rather than learning real lessons from its failures.

The Justice Ministry has already explained that bringing the participants in the massacre to justice is a top priority, and that tremendous resources are being devoted to it. That’s precisely the path of a law-abiding country – to guarantee a just trial, even in the most difficult cases. But the draft bill makes that need superfluous, offering “swift justice” at the expense of clarifying the truth. Such a result isn’t justice; it’s a degradation of justice.

The American experience in Guantanamo is a clear warning signal: Two decades after the establishment of the military court, most of the accused who were brought before it and were accused of participating in the 9/11 attacks have yet to be convicted, and the system is bearing the stain of the unfair trials and the cruel incarceration. Israel, which is a signatory to the human rights convention and the anti-torture convention, cannot allow itself to repeat the same mistake.

The present proposal determines that the special court can judge based on Israeli law “regarding the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide” – in which the death sentence is almost unique. This closes the circle: A political tribunal that bypasses the rules of law can also execute. A combination of show trials and an irreversible punishment is a recipe for war crimes. The death penalty, which revokes the right to life and causes tremendous physical and emotional suffering, is considered the ultimate torture worldwide. Any mistake in such a process will become lethal, especially when it’s flawed from the start.

In most Western countries, and in effect in most countries worldwide, the death penalty has long been abolished. Israel, which for decades boasted as being part of the democratic world, will isolate itself even further if it returns to implementing it ,and expanding the cases in which it can be imposed. Establishing a political court that can conduct executions won’t strengthen Israel; it will weaken its status and give critics proof that it has lost its way.

In addition to the international damage, the draft bill would actually harm the victims of the October 7 crimes. A show trial in which the result is a foregone conclusion doesn’t reveal the truth; it conceals it and is perceived as such. The families of the victims, who are entitled to know exactly what happened on that terrible day, will get a political display rather than a real investigation: Justice will be denied to them, in their name.

Israel has already proven that it’s capable of rising above the desire for revenge, and even when the Nazis and their collaborators were brought to trial, it was carried out through a proper process that became an international example of justice and proportionality. That’s what a genuine law-abiding country does. A country is tested not only on the battlefield, but also in its courtrooms. The way the Knesset chooses to behave with regard to political tribunals, the death penalty and incarceration with torture will make it clear whether it wants to return to the family of democratic nations or has officially declared the elimination of the desire for justice, replacing it with the value of revenge.

The author is Executive Director of the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel.

This article is reproduced in its entirety

 

© Copyright JFJFP 2026