Ayelett Shani interviews Safa Younes in Haaretz on 17 October 2025:
Please introduce yourself.
I’m Safa, a resident of Jaffa and a social worker by profession. Over the years, I received a master’s degree in social work and another in business administration. Recently, I also completed a master’s in emergency and disaster management. In the past, I have worked in social entrepreneurship, especially community initiatives for the advancement of women in Arab Israeli society, and I served as director of the socioeconomic development unit of the Ministry of Social Equality’s Authority for Economic Development of Arab Society.
Last year, I changed course and now, as a social worker, I provide support for families who have experienced traumatic loss. This form of counseling represents a kind of convergence between the personal and the professional: Less than a year ago I was widowed. Of course, the cases I work with are different. Most of them, very sadly, involve loss in the wake of homicides in Arab society – in Ramle-Lod and Jaffa. The violence among the Arab population is breaking all records. Every year is bloodier than the last. The phenomenon has become completely normalized. Homicides have become part of life. [The 200th such incident this year occurred on Wednesday.]
Before I started working with these families, I was shocked by every case but managed to go on with my life. Since I’ve been visiting homes and meeting parents, bereaved siblings, widows and orphaned children, I can no longer just move on. The main part of my work is simply to be with them in their pain. I don’t always have something wise to say to such people, but I can give them permission to vent their pain, because many times the attitude, especially in regard to women, is “Be strong.”
The women are in any case used to being strong, their whole environment expects them to be strong, but they also need the space to fall apart a little and that’s not usually an option in the family setting. Many people tell me: “My parents are already worn out, so I won’t cry next to them.” Each person is not a number but an entire world, and the grief is so enormous. Many times, after leaving an encounter with such a family, it takes hours for me to calm down and return to myself.
Why is that? You’re an experienced social worker and you’ve seen many difficult things. What do you see in these homes?
I encounter not only loss but everything around it. Beyond the mourning and shock, there’s fear and despair. The families know that the dispute won’t end with a death. A man whose brother was killed grasps that he can’t leave the house now, because they’ll get to him, too. Not all the incidents are contract killings. There are cases of accidental killings, of mistaken identity, of people who were killed because they were in the wrong place at the wrong time.
It’s beyond comprehension. I work with quite a few families like that, who simply don’t know why the person was killed. For them, the pain is even greater. When there’s an active dispute, they know it’s a possible scenario. When it’s just a mistake, the shock is overwhelming. They [the killers] thought he was someone else, so they killed him. They entered a store to kill the proprietor who owes them money and on the way, also shot and killed an employee – because they could. Months later, the family’s still in shock. And the pain is truly intolerable because they want answers and there are none.
There are lengthy feuds between large families with hundreds of members and the family that pays the price isn’t necessarily connected to the crime itself. There are sometimes even families of thousands of people, who don’t even remember the reason for the feud anymore, but the killing on both sides continues. It can go on like that for years. The thing is that those actually involved in illegal activity protect themselves.
So the branches of the family who are involved in crime look after themselves?
Yes. They come from that world, so they know how to do that. They have protected homes with fences and cameras. They use “soldiers.” So in the end, the people who get hurt are other branches of the family – those who, even though they belong to that family, were far from the world of violence and crime. Regular people who go to work every day. It’s far easier to get to and attack them. The pain is horrific.
Parents tell me how they safeguarded the children their whole lives, made sure that they would not have to pay a price just for having a certain family name, ensured that they received an education, acquired a profession. One mother told me: “My son was a schoolteacher, a good husband, a good father – why did they kill him? His whole life I watched over him. In my darkest dreams, I never imagined he could be a target.” On top of the grief, there’s frustration, anger, helplessness. The mothers and the widows are paying such a steep price for something they had nothing to do with.
And for the men in the family the killing is a wake-up call.
After a homicide, the men in the family realize they’re now in the crosshairs, especially if several members of that family have been killed. One after another, sometimes two at once. Those are the most difficult cases in terms of consequences, because the men in the family – the brothers, the cousins, men who previously worked, functioned, provided for their families – stop working and go underground. They barricade themselves at home, and there’s no one to support the family. They can’t even go to a National Insurance Institute branch to sign up [for unemployment benefits] because it’s too dangerous. The debts start to pile up and the situation at home deteriorates. That’s usually the point when I encounter the family: Everyone’s at home, they already have problems with the Law Enforcement and Collection Authority, and they need help.
Do the children also stay home?
If there are older children in the family, say age 13 and up, they too are at risk and stay home.
How long, on average, does a family like this lock itself in its home?
For a few months. Sometimes even longer. Some sleep during the day and stay awake all night. The ones who pay the steepest price, besides the victims themselves, are the children.
And many families who were on a normative life trajectory end up deviating from it.
Yes. And one only hopes they don’t fall into crime. It’s bad enough that they’re confined to their homes, racking up debts and barely surviving. I try to connect them to support systems, offer some kind of therapeutic response. But the resources are very limited. We ceased to be a welfare state long ago.
On the other hand, if we don’t try to step in, there’s a very great risk that their situation will deteriorate, especially that of the younger children. The mother says to me, “What future do they have now? What will become of them? They won’t finish high school; they won’t have a profession.” The future is very bleak, you see? It’s so overwhelming that the loss itself is no longer at the center. They’re in terrible pain, but there are so many additional difficulties to cope with.
It’s tough when the whole extended family is confined at home; it’s a pressure cooker. Doesn’t that aggravate the situation? Lead to domestic violence?
Under those conditions, everything you can imagine actually does happen. I’m working with a family in which four sons have already been killed. I came because of one death, and then it turned out there had been a double killing a few years earlier, and another one before that.
I see the child who wasn’t yet born when his father was killed, and now his uncle has also been killed. He’s traumatized – he doesn’t remember his father, but the uncle was there, and now this [recent] homicide has reopened the trauma. What therapy can I offer a mother who’s lost four children and is now terrified for those who remain? I ask: “If they don’t leave the house, how will you subsist?” And she replies, “My four children died because they went to work. It’s better if we don’t have food but they are alive.” So everyone stays home, suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and taking medications. Even the slightest noise makes them jump. And the women, of course, need to be strong while also coping with debts, economic difficulties, their children’s difficulties and the problems of the other men in the family.
Do you know of cases in which women descended into crime?
It’s impossible to really know; I personally haven’t encountered that. These women are living in hell. There’s one mother whose only child, an 18-year-old son, was killed. He wasn’t involved in crime or anything. On the contrary: His whole life he studied, worked and supported his mother after her husband died and left debts. When I spoke with the Jewish lawyer who had dealt with the case [relating to her financial situation] and knew the boy, he was shocked. “Why was he killed? He was such a good kid,” he said. I had to explain to him that it didn’t matter. His surname determined his fate.
Horrible.
Yes. So I try to do whatever is possible. I’m promoting a community project to train guidance counselors in schools to respond to the needs of children whose parents were homicide victims – how to treat a child whose father was killed along with their classmates and other children from the same family who attend the school. Often, counselors and teachers don’t know how to broach the subject or whether they’re even allowed to talk about it.
I think they should: The children, and not only those whose parent was killed, need legitimization in order to talk about their fears. All the others in the class are also afraid. Very much so. They think, “Will the same thing happen to my father or to my older brother?” Children from families that have lost several relatives are in a state of continuous trauma.
It’s impossible for them to process that and start to heal.
Correct. Because the trauma doesn’t end. It is ongoing. There’s one family who started therapy after the mother was killed, and then their uncle was killed, and a few months later the grandfather. The children are terrified, but they don’t know how to express their fear: It is manifested in violent behavior in school – with talk like, “Yes, but we killed two of theirs,” and “You got it even before this.”
That’s how schoolchildren talk? How old are they – 12? 13?
Even younger. Such talk protects them, makes them feel strong. In schools, the reality of homicides is already a matter of routine. It’s what the children hear and talk about: ‘He was killed like this, the other one was killed like that, this one was shot, that one was blown up.’ Videos of the killings are often circulated [on social media] and children see them. The child whose father was killed witnesses the incident. I know cases of families who weren’t involved in any crime until the homicide took place, and then the children of the victim, or his brother, decided to avenge his death.
Yes, unfortunately that also happens. If the police did their job properly and people were convicted and sent to prison for murder, maybe the endless cycle would be broken somewhat. But as long as nothing is done, as long as the killers walk about freely, people live with pain and seek revenge. You know, there are cases where families tell me that they even know who the perpetrator is – there’s evidence, blood on the shirt, on the shoes – and the police claim it’s not enough. The person is arrested and is released a week later. There’s no greater pain than that of a family who knows who the killers are and sees them walking about with impunity.
Do families talk to you about revenge? Is that something you hear?
Not so often. Look, I work mainly with women from families that are less directly connected to the feuds. Families that are more closely involved don’t want me to visit them at all. They ghost me. They won’t invite a social worker into their home. They also tend to suffer less from economic difficulties. The families I treat face so many hardships at once: the loss, the grief, the economic problems, the hiding in the house. And the children are in a bad way. Everyone is in a bad way. It’s a real dilemma – what the boundaries are of my role and what I can actually do.
I understand you. It’s difficult for you also because the response you can offer is partial, if anything. You’re emptying a bucket with a spoon.
That’s part of my way of coping: to understand the helplessness. At first, I thought I would show up and solve all their problems for them. Over time, I realized that won’t happen – but that being there is also important. You know, sometimes when we’re in profound distress, we’re not actually looking for a solution. Sometimes all we want is for someone to hear us and say a kind word. I learned that myself when I lost my husband. What I really needed wasn’t to be told what to do. I wanted people to be with me, to listen if I spoke. From my point of view, that was more important than concrete help.
Of course, the people we are talking about also need concrete help. But the attentiveness and presence I offer are also important: to be by their side, witness their pain, give them a voice, explain that I see the injustice that was done them.
To validate their experience.
Validation is so important. It’s absolutely critical, because these people get no response from the establishment. Not from the police, not from support systems. A huge disaster befell them, but despite their pain and tragedy they’re transparent. No one cares about them, no one sees them, no one helps them. It’s true that sometimes there really is no horizon for such people. But I’m a great believer in humanity. I believe in its resourcefulness, in its ability to survive. The ability to change. I try to hold that place for them. Sometimes it takes a long time, sometimes they really are too worn down.
We’ve hardly talked about the women in Arab society who are killed.
I also provide counseling, of course, in cases related to gender – that is, of violence and killing targeting women – even though they’re not the majority. There are women who are killed by their partner or by a relative. And there’s another phenomenon I’m familiar with from past interviews: Within the framework of years-long feuds between families, women who were marked as “problematic” were chosen by their families to pay the price of the feud. In fact, their own family put out the contract.
It’s a known thing, and so horrific for the children. When they lose their mother they also lose the security of the family, because the family is effectively to blame for their mother’s death.
What happens to those children? Who looks after them?
In most cases, it’s the grandmother who takes that on herself. If she’s the victim’s mother, then obviously she too is mentally devastated and will harbor immense anger toward the family that is to blame for her daughter’s death. These are very complex cases involving serious trauma and very complicated relationships, which sadly and mainly continue to impact the children. Lately, I’ve encountered cases of women connected to the so-called gray market. One woman’s son had problems relating to his dealings in the gray market, so she was killed in revenge. Or there’s a man who’s entangled with it but they can’t get to him because he’s in hiding, so they target his wife or child.
Two years ago, a woman activist against violence in Arab society told me that in the past there had been a red line concerning attacks on women and children. That line has been crossed.
The families tell me that all the time. That beforehand, only men were attacked – even if they weren’t involved in anything. But now they shoot everyone. If, in the past, they [the killers] spotted their target, as it were, walking with his wife or his elderly mother, they would wait until she wasn’t by his side and only then attacked. Today, they shoot both of them. All the lines have been crossed. Women and children are being shot. Bombs are planted in cars even if it’s known that the target’s little children are in the car with him. Women live with a total lack of security. In one of the families I’m working with, the father – an older man, a good man –was killed, apparently because of one of his children’s activities. Now none of his daughters leave the house. They know they’re in the cross hairs.
In the meantime, it looks as though the bleakest scenarios are coming to pass. I understood there’s also growing involvement of international organized crime.
The lack of police deterrence is very significant. There’s now also this matter of “soldiers.” I started to hear about children of 13, 14, 15 who are given 5,000 shekels [about $1,540] and some sort of energy pill. These clearly at-risk children have no horizon. Obviously, no one is looking after them. Look, it’s a complicated problem with so many different angles: the involvement of crime organizations, blood feuds, at-risk youth with nothing to lose. And they really have nothing to lose, because the police create no deterrence. How will a child learn that it’s wrong to do what he is doing if he knows nothing will happen to him?
You personally moved from the rewarding world of successful social entrepreneurship to such a despairing place.
These are worlds I hadn’t been in touch with for a long time. I think it has to do with my personal loss. After I experienced it, I felt that I had resources, something I could give. But the truth is that I never imagined things would be like this. I thought I would be supporting bereaved people. I never imagined how many more problems and complexities I would encounter.
You are due next week to participate as a speaker within the framework of TEDx Jaffa Women. Will you talk about the violence?
No. The violence won’t be the center of my talk, even though it’s so important. I think I’ll talk about listening, actually.
You told me that you’re optimistic, but this interview has been so upsetting and disheartening. Where does the optimism come from?
It’s impossible to do what I’m doing without optimism. I’m optimistic, but realistic. I understand that it’s impossible to change everything, but it’s possible to do something. One can support, speak out, create capabilities within the community. There are things we can do to help these people rehabilitate their lives. Sometimes it’s possible to grow from within the pain.
This article is reproduced in its entirety