The great betrayal: Why Arab and Muslim rulers backed Trump’s Gaza plan


Regional leaders have responded to the bravery and steadfastness that Gaza's Palestinians have shown with fear, cowardice and self-interest US President Donald Trump attends a multilateral meeting with leaders of Qatar, Jordan, Turkey, Pakistan, Indonesia, Egypt, United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia, during the United Nations General Assembly, 23 September 2025, in New York

David Hearst writes in Middle East Eye on 1 October 2025:

Arab and Muslim leaders can claim to have been duped into giving their backing to the plan unveiled by US President Donald Trump on Monday.

The plan announced in Washington was substantially different to the one they agreed to in New York. But that is the charitable way of reading what they have done.

Betrayal is another word that comes to mind.  A betrayal performed as a genocide is in full motion and which Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been given a green light by Trump to continue.

The Qataris are furious they were written out of a mediation role and that Trump refused to delay the announcement. The Egyptians, too, are furious that the role of the Palestinian Authority (PA) has been downgraded and that Israeli forces will always remain in Rafah and along the border with Sinai.  But the names of each country are still on the statement welcoming the plan and neither have said or done anything to withdraw from it.

Either way, each of the eight regional nations that backed this agreement is serving the people of Gaza a bitter and bleak reward for two years of enduring the worst military onslaught in the history of this conflict.

For them, there is to be no light at the end of the tunnel. Only a different form of occupation and a different form of siege.

Just at that point in history when world opinion has definitively turned against Israel and just as more countries than ever before have recognised the Palestinian state, Arab and Muslim leaders have signed up to a plan that ensures that a viable state can never emerge from the rubble of Israel’s vengeance.

The regional states can claim they stopped the mass ethnic cleansing of Gaza, the Israeli occupation, and brought the UN agencies back into Gaza. But the keys to each remain in Netanyahu’s hands.

No agency
There is no guarantee they have stopped ethnic cleansing and genocide, because under this agreement, Israeli forces are not leaving the strip, and Netanyahu is the one who decides how quickly and how much of Gaza his forces hand over to the proposed International Stabilisation Force (ISF).He is also free to decide how much aid and reconstruction materials to send in. There is no timetable for such a withdrawal.

But there is every guarantee that this postwar plan will stifle at birth Gaza reemerging under a Palestinian leadership of any kind.  Under this plan, there is no role for any Palestinian leadership in the rebuilding of Gaza. Gaza is definitively split from the Occupied West Bank by this agreement and all thoughts of joining the two have been jettisoned.

More ….

© Copyright JFJFP 2026