The Zionist opposition thinks it can protest dictatorship while ignoring Palestinians


The anti-government demonstrators on Kaplan Street in Tel Aviv look to countries like Hungary to understand the transformation of Israel into an authoritarian regime. But the model for emulation is right under their noses Over 1,000 people attend a demonstration against Israel’s war on Gaza in Tel Aviv, 18 January 2024

Amira Hass writes in Haaretz on 31 December 2025:

Even before they received their moniker, the demonstrators on Kaplan Street had numerous warnings that their comfortable lifestyle, which seemed to them value-centered and democratic, was at risk.

Various groups consisting of other citizens faced them, singing other tunes. These groups sounded an SOS based on facts, Jewish and universal values, considerations of worthwhileness, lessons from history and common sense – all to no avail.

The future Kaplanists did not listen or found excuses and justifications, not thinking of exercising their power while they still had it. In other words, when they were central and influential in the legal and education systems, in the academic world and economy, in the media and in the civil service.

Now, they and their representatives in center and non-Bibi-ist right-wing parties – deprived of their power – look to Hungary to understand the process that enables Israel to be transformed into an authoritarian, up to a dictatorial regime. But the model for emulation, which has proven to be successful and paved the way to dictatorship for Jews, is right under their noses. This model is based on:

1) Shattering the principle of a division between the different branches of government: This is exactly what characterizes the military regime instated in the territory that was conquered in 1967, and upheld by generations of military governors.

In these areas, the executive branch also holds legislative and judiciary authority. Army jurists, whom no Palestinian subject ever elected, served and serve as “legislators,” among whose edicts is the prohibition on demonstrations.

In military courts, there is no pretense of representation. All the accused are Palestinians, and all prosecutors and judges are Israelis, usually Jewish, with a few Druze judges and, obviously, some settlers. Generations of future politicians and jurists were raised on these dictatorial practices, imbibing their principles and building their careers on them.

2) Material discrimination for the benefit of a particular societal sector that is close to the rulers at the expense of other sectors: What is that if not the regime of dispossesion, which all Israeli apparatuses and democratically-elected politicians have invented, developed, operated and oiled, transferring to Jewish citizens of Israel land and property belonging to the Palestinian nation on both sides of the Green Line 1967 border? All this with the imprimatur of the courts, at all their levels.

3) The persecution of opponents of the regime overhaul and the employment of disproportionate policing and punitive methods against them: The finest Israeli brains invented and improved methods of muzzling and distancing Palestinian social and political leaders while deterring others. From a prohibition on demonstrations to false indictments, from administrative detention, through remand until the end of legal proceedings, to expulsion.

4) Double standards in implementing laws: The forgiving attitude of the legal system to the violence of Israelis of a certain ilk toward others began decades before the watch of Yariv Levin and Itamar Ben-Gvir, when authorities turned a blind eye to the violence of settlers.

Whoever constructed this original version of no democracy when the state was established, and in 1967, did not listen to the Palestinians, and did not heed the warnings of the left. Neither did they learn from the expertise of jurists specializing in human rights.

They thought that democracy for Jews would continue to flourish on the back of our military junta ruling Palestinians and robbing their lands, and that all Jews would continue to profit from both worlds.

The “Kaplanists” continue to sanctify and hold in high esteem an army protecting settlements and expulsion. For them, democracy is identified with participation in its crimes in the West Bank and in the Gaza Strip.

Despairingly, the vast majority of the Zionist opposition is still convinced that one can oppose a dictatorship over Jews while ignoring its foundations, while excluding and boycotting its first and main targets – the Palestinians.

This article is reproduced in its entirety

 

© Copyright JFJFP 2026