The Haaretz lead editorial on 20 January 2026:
Rafi Marciano’s diary was never supposed to have been written. An educator, 75 when he died, should not have gone to prison and skillfully described the reality of life for prisoners in an Israeli jail. But that’s what happened. On faded, squared pages in a small exercise book, beside illiterate prisoners – Marciano wrote.
On his behalf, but also on theirs. About the bedbugs and ticks that fill the bedding. About the meager, rotten food. About the despair, the loneliness, the daily struggle to maintain one’s humanity in a place that is designed to wear it down.
Every year, the Public Defender’s Office issues a report on conditions in the Israel Prison Service. The problems recur: from severe overcrowding to the dire shortage of rehabilitation facilities, everything is in violation of the regulations. The last report states that almost half the prisoners are held in “inhumane living conditions.” The infringement of the most basic rights of dignity and rehabilitation have become a matter of routine.
“It’s hard to describe in words the sense of overcrowding, suffocation, the conditions of heat and cold and the poor sanitation that characterize the prisoners’ harsh experience,” the report reads. In that sense, Marciano’s diary is the necessary appendix to the familiar data that is published every year.
Nonetheless, when reading his diary and his descriptions of the people withering before his eyes, it should be remembered: It was written from the special wing for the elderly and sick at Maasiyahu Prison. In prison roulette, where no one knows where they’ll end up, there are even worse places – in the criminal wings, let alone the security wings. There, with government approval, the incarceration conditions have worsened since the outbreak of the war, and there have been several cases of dead prisoners whose bodies showed signs of violence amid repeated testimonies of severe hunger.
The national security minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir, is definitely not bothered by the rights of security prisoners. But a policy that tramples on human rights, in which people are stripped of their humanity, is not limited to the security wing. It turns out that it extends, albeit to a lesser extent, to the elderly and sick people Marciano met. As he personally experienced.
Prisons are not just places to jail people. Part of their purpose is to offer prisoners a new path, a commitment to treatment and rehabilitation for a reformed return to the outside. So long as that purpose is abandoned in practice, prison is nothing but an instrument of blind punishment. Marciano’s diary is an indictment. And the defendants are not just the prison service, the National Security Ministry or the state, but Israeli society as a whole, which accepts it.
This article is reproduced in its entirety