Katherine Hearst reports in Middle East Eye on 12 May 2026:
A leading human rights barrister who represented Palestine Action defendants in the UK has won an appeal against a contempt of court case.
Rajiv Menon KC was accused of breaching the judge’s directions in a closing speech he delivered at the conclusion of the first trial at Woolwich Crown Court involving six Palestine action defendants accused of causing criminal damage to weapons at an Israeli army factory outside Bristol.
The defendants were subsequently cleared of charges of aggravated burglary. They were then retried, with four of them convicted of criminal damage last week.
The proceedings against Menon are thought to be unprecedented in English legal history.
During the trial, the presiding judge, Justice Johnson, directed lawyers that their closing speeches could not invite the jury to disregard the court’s ruling or law, and barred them from reminding the jury of its right to acquit on conscience – known as the principle of “jury equity”.
In his closing remarks, Menon, who has 30 years of experience and who represented defendant Charlotte Head in both trials, read out an inscription on a plaque at the Old Bailey commemorating Bushell’s Case of 1670, which first “established the right of juries to give their verdicts according to their convictions”.
Menon told jurors that the defendants had been “restricted” when giving evidence about their knowledge of Israeli arms company Elbit Systems’ role in Israel’s war on Gaza, and that it would be “ridiculous” for jurors to ignore that wider context and its impact on the defendants.