Israel to redirect $68 million from Arab social programs to Shin Bet, police


The funds, approved despite legal warnings, will boost the Shin Bet's role in non-security crime and expand police units, as far-right ministers push a controversial shift from social support to law enforcement A protest against police inaction in the Arab-Israeli community in Nazareth, 3 October 2019

Josh Breiner and and Ran Shimoni report in Haaretz on 15 December 2025:

The Israeli government has approved slashing 220 million shekels ($68 million) from social programs for the Arab-Israeli community and giving the money instead to the Shin Bet security service and the police to bolster the fight against crime in that community.

According to the decision, promoted by far-right Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Likud Minister May Golan, some of the money will be used to expand the police’s Lahav 433 unit, which deals with serious crimes, at a time when Golan herself is under criminal investigation by that unit.

Under Sunday’s decision, the Shin Bet will take on an unprecedented role in addressing non-security-related crime in the Arab community. The move was approved by the agency’s new director, David Zini, after all of his predecessors had opposed it.

Of the 220 million shekels, 100 million will go to the Shin Bet and the rest to the police. Of the total amount the government approved for cuts, about 100 million shekels will go to the Shin Bet, with the remainder allocated to the police. According to the government-approved proposal, roughly 81 million shekels intended for the Shin Bet will be dedicated to technology and intelligence infrastructure, while 32 million shekels shared between the two agencies will be used to establish a joint Shin Bet–police unit.

Golan and Ben-Gvir had originally wanted to cut the entire 2.4 billion shekels (almost $750 million) earmarked for social programs in the Arab community under a five-year plan approved earlier, but had to make do instead with less than 10 percent of that sum.

The fund transfer was approved despite the criticisms voiced in an opinion by the legal adviser to the Prime Minister’s Office. As Haaretz has previously reported, the opinion said the proposal was made without any proper staff work. Moreover, it said, it will result in the existing five-year plan and the new crime-fighting plan operating simultaneously with no coordination between them.

Moreover, “Even though this is a complementary plan that focuses on law enforcement, it was drafted without the participation of all the relevant enforcement agencies,” the opinion added.

It also said that while the plan allocates funding and staff positions to the police and the Shin Bet, it provides no similar increase for the prosecution, social services or the courts. This, it argued, makes no sense, because “it may create a structural imbalance and bottlenecks that will undermine the functioning and effectiveness of the entire law enforcement system.”

In October, the Ministerial Committee for Legislation gave preliminary approval to a bill that would define organized crime rings as terrorist organizations, thereby enabling the Shin Bet to use the same tools against organized crime that it does against threats to national security. Ben-Gvir pressured Zini to back the move, even though Shin Bet professionals opposed it for fear of creating a slippery slope that would lead to the agency unacceptably using these tools against civilians.

This article is reproduced in its entirety

© Copyright JFJFP 2026