Matan Golan reports in Haaretz on 11 November 2026:
Anyone driving on the Alon Road near the northern West Bank settlement of Beka’ot will find a yellow gate standing on the other side of the road – locked and abandoned – between concrete blocks and piles of dirt. Beyond the gate are the community of Ras al-Ahmar and the villages of Atuf and Tammun. Jordan Valley activists have for years called it the “water gate,” since water from the Atuf well used to be transported through it to isolated northern Jordan Valley communities.
There was a time when the residents of Ras al-Ahmar, located at the northern edge of the fertile Tammun Valley and east of the nearby villages, did not have to transport water. Pipes ran from Atuf directly to their homes and across the widespread lands in the area. But in March, during construction of the “scarlet thread” barrier – a fence intended to thwart terror threats from the northern West Bank to the Jordan Valley – the pipes supplying water to the 59 homes that house 202 people were cut.
Since then, the community has had no continuous water supply, as residents await activists to deliver jerricans from the opposite direction. However, the water gate is now hermetically sealed. Additional yellow gates block all roads leading to the community, preventing vehicle movement.
And in villages where herding communities reside within firing zones in the South Hebron Hills, a water crisis that began weeks ago is intensifying. There the circumstances differ slightly, but the result is similar: military actions prevent water and food supply, creating pressure for the immediate expulsion of Palestinians.
In both cases, petitions and requests for interim relief have been filed with the High Court of Justice, so far without success. The military claims these represent Palestinian incursions into firing zones, where civilian entry is prohibited. However, no enforcement actions are taken against settlers who build outposts in those same firing zones and travel freely within them. In fact, last summer the Israel Defense Forces Central Command removed lands from firing zones that had been encroached upon by settler construction – a move expected to accelerate their regularization.
Since the 1970s, Israel has declared that 18 percent of West Bank lands are firing zones. They were ostensibly intended for IDF training, but in a 1979 Ministerial Committee for Settlement discussion, Ariel Sharon said the firing zone initiative was meant “to keep reserves for settlement.” This approach has continued since then. For example, a senior Central Command officer said in the previous decade that training in the West Bank firing zones was intended to reduce the number of Palestinians living there.
‘Soldier asked why we hadn’t left’
According to the military, “urgent security needs” were also behind the construction of the barrier in the heart of the Jordan Valley. A January petition filed by attorney Tawfiq Jabarin on behalf of area residents argued that the barrier’s construction would disconnect communities living east of it from the villages upon which they rely, causing widespread loss of livelihood by preventing access to thousands of agricultural dunams in the Tammun Valley. Two months later, the water pipes were cut, and all fears materialized.
During a Haaretz visit to the site in March, Palestinians were evacuating agricultural infrastructure from the eastern part of the valley. In an October visit, several sheep-raising compounds were already empty and abandoned. “A soldier came, and asked why we hadn’t left yet,” says M., a resident of the area. “There’s no food, no water. Some families have already left. Twelve hours ago, I gave the sheep a little water to wet their lips. I haven’t been able to let them drink as much as they want for a month.”
In April, the court ruled that a tour should be coordinated with the residents, partly to repair water infrastructure and to inform them of the gate’s opening hours giving them access to land east of the barrier. Since then, residents have been waiting for the decision to be implemented. How can one survive without water? It’s impossible. So they improvise. “Every day since they cut the pipes, we try to lay water pipes and the military cuts them. Again and again,” a resident of the nearby village says.
Until about two months ago, residents held on by using improvised pipes and by driving on winding roads. “But in mid-September, all the roads were hermetically sealed, and a confiscation operation began,” M. says. “The military patrols to check for vehicles, and regardless of their location, they say it’s a closed military area and they will confiscate them. As a result, people themselves removed their tractors from the area. We switched to using donkeys to bring food and water, but even the strongest donkey cannot carry enough water for an entire herd.”
According to residents, every day they appeal to the District Coordination and Liaison Office, requesting permission to transfer water and food and to repair the pipes – but to no avail. “In what country in the world does a military prevent water? Water is the weapon,” one resident says.
In response to a petition on the matter, the state claimed in September that “difficulties arose” in the coordination mechanism, and that additional pipes laid were destroyed as part of the works, and a repair plan is being formulated. However, it added that the pipes are considered illegal construction, their repair will not legitimize them and they may be destroyed again. According to the state, for weeks water pipes have been repeatedly laid in the dead of night along the barrier’s route “in an uncoordinated manner that violates the provisions of the law,” and this cannot be accepted.
“When an entire community and its herds are left without water, and the coordination mechanism is not functioning, it is not surprising that residents try to restore water supply on their own to survive,” Jabarin replied to the High Court, adding that responsibility for the situation lies with the state and not with the residents. Since March, there have also been reports of the destruction of six wells in the area. In response to a Haaretz inquiry in October, an IDF spokesman said that “illegally built wells are being destroyed, alongside dealing with water pumping equipment established without permits.”
Unlike many communities expelled during the war, most Ras al-Ahmar residents are not Bedouin but are people from Tammun who settled on the outskirts of the village to raise sheep. They are fully dependent on the village for services, but movement to there is now prohibited. “This is my home; all my childhood was here,” T. says. “Until 1967, we lived on lands farther from the village, and the military pushed us in this direction. I have a deed of ownership for this land; the Civil Administration recognizes our ownership. I can’t imagine living anywhere else. We have roots here. But I raise sheep for a living, and you can’t raise sheep inside the village.”
Haaretz spoke with other residents who hold deeds of ownership for the regulated Palestinian land on which their homes and sheep pens are located, land that was declared a firing zone in the 1980s. Many of the community’s homes encroach into the area by between a few meters to hundreds of meters.
In residents’ testimonies, a settler by the name of Haim, who serves in the regional defense battalions, is repeatedly mentioned. They claim he abuses them, and directs the soldiers. “Haim fights us through water,” T. says. “Sometimes he drives military vehicles, sometimes a regular jeep. He comes at night, and cuts and uproots the pipes.” According to another resident, “Haim controls the military. In my opinion, he gives orders to the military and not the other way around.” A third resident adds: “We don’t sleep at night. Haim comes to houses at night with a mask, breaks security cameras. Sometimes he comes with soldiers, and then they threaten us, saying this is land for Jews and there’s no place for Arabs. ‘Go to Tubas,’ ‘Go to Tammun.’ Haim searches the house, breaks things. The children start crying when he arrives.”
According to estimates, at least a third of the families have been forced to leave due to the water shortage. The closed gates open easily when it comes to leaving. Among some of the remaining families, women and children have moved to Tammun during the week, since the walk to school is too long. In October, one of the soldiers at the checkpoint told Haaretz that they were instructed not to transfer water to Ras al-Ahmar residents.
An IDF spokesman did not respond to Haaretz’s question regarding the directive to open the gate only for departing families. According to him, the soldiers operate in accordance with High Court directives, and these are firing zones forbidden for civilian entry. The military also claimed that the barrier does not prevent pedestrian passage, and that “the community is allowed vehicular entry and exit from their residential compound via a nearby alternative route.”
However, according to residents, this is a long, rough bypass route that was also closed in October. During a Haaretz visit to the site in the middle of the month, two teams of soldiers were asked where the alternative route was. They replied they were not aware of one.
A few days after the visit, the entry of two water tankers and three trucks to transport the harvest from banana plantations was coordinated via the gate separating Ras al-Ahmar from Atuf. According to the petition, two tankers are barely enough for one herding family and its flock over two days. One of the trucks carried fodder for the sheep, but Haaretz learned that when the Palestinians began to unload it, the soldiers and a settler who arrived at the scene ordered them to reload the food, claiming that there was permission only for the transfer of water and bananas.
On October 21, the petitioners appealed to the court, requesting the urgent opening of access roads and permission for transferring water and food supply and for accessing essential services. When the request was first submitted about a month earlier, Justice Daphne Barak-Erez ruled that the state must update “what has been done,” but nothing happened. In their renewed petition, the residents wrote: “If the honorable court does not grant the requested remedies immediately, no residents will remain in the area, and the expulsion project will be completed.”
The state did not address the pipe repair issue, but replied that “the works in the relevant subsections have been completed,” and that from now on, the gate will open twice a day at specified hours. The following day, tractors with water tankers arrived at the gate at the designated times – but it remained closed, according to another petition filed by the residents. “It appears that the respondents are wasting time and delaying permission for food and water entry, hoping that all residents will evacuate and no resident will remain in the area,” they wrote.
One of the villages in Firing Zone 918 in the South Hebron Hills after the demolition of Palestinian structures by the military, last week.
The continued process seemed to prove the point: Barak-Erez ordered the state to respond on the matter; the state delayed another day and then claimed there was a “local malfunction.” An IDF spokesman told Haaretz that “due to weather conditions, the force got stuck on the way [to open the gate that day] and did not manage to arrive at the specified time,” and that “the IDF regrets this and is working to comply with the agreed arrangement.”
In practice, the gate also remained locked in the following days. According to residents, the soldiers refused to open it. Only on Thursday, for the first time in months, the gate was opened twice for vehicles transporting food and water to the community. This gives residents a little breathing room, but is not a solution enabling a normal routine.
2,000 people with no access to water
In the villages of the South Hebron Hills , the story is different, but the outcome is the same. In the 1980s, the Masafer Yatta area was declared Firing Zone 918. In 2022, after a a two-decade struggle, the High Court ruled there were no permanent residences in the area on the eve of the declaration, despite contradictory information presented by the residents. This enabled the expulsion of eight villages located deep within the firing zone, in the part called “wet,” where live-fire training is supposed to take place. But the state did not implement the expulsion directly through eviction orders; instead, it focused on destroying Palestinian structures.
Concurrently, since 2023, about 10 outposts have been established in the firing zone, including at least three farms in coordination with the political echelon. One of them, “Edge of the Desert Farm,” was established in the heart of the “wet” part. This did not prevent the military from claiming again in June 2025 that Palestinian structures harm training and operational readiness. No similar steps were taken against the settlers.
Demolition orders are pending against most Palestinian structures in the area, and the demolition rate has increased in recent months. In many villages, residents live in temporary structures and cave dwellings that have survived the waves of destruction. Going out to pasture is barely possible due to settler and outpost violence. Since these are unrecognized villages, there is no water infrastructure. And over the years, the military has destroyed many water cisterns that served them, making them completely dependent on the transporting of water and food for both people and livestock from nearby settlements.
But in recent weeks, a policy prohibiting uncoordinated vehicle movement has also been implemented here; any vehicle doing so may be confiscated. As a result, movement between the villages has almost completely ceased, immediately leading to a significant water shortage. A petition that attorney Neta Amar Schiff filed in mid-October stated that the confiscation of vehicles imposes an actual siege on the residents, and it is intended to accelerate their forced transfer. According to a report by the Masafer Yatta council attached to the petition, more than 2,000 residents are left without access to water, health services, food and medicine, and the remaining amount of food for livestock are sufficient for only a few days, which is expected to lead to high animal mortality.
All this is happening while settlers continue to travel in the firing zone and harass residents who dare to move in the open area: In the last two weeks, settlers threw stones at a transit van used to transport children. In another incident, they attacked a Palestinian who tried to transport food for livestock on a tractor, and he was evacuated for medical treatment with a head injury. On Fridays, Israelis are also allowed to hike for pleasure in the firing zone in coordination with the military, while Palestinians are forbidden to move in the area.
The residents claimed in their petition that they are discriminated against, since the coordination procedure is enforced only on them, and that the policy of confiscating vehicles is aimed at leading to an indirect evacuation that will prevent “the appearance of an anti-humanitarian evacuation.” They submitted an urgent request for an interim order to stop the confiscations, as they do not have enough water and food to survive in the villages until the petition is decided. But Justice Barak-Erez gave the state almost two weeks to respond.
In response to the petition, the military announced about a week ago that vehicle entry to Masafer Yatta for transporting water and food and for bringing in teachers and medical teams would be allowed twice a week, on Mondays and Wednesdays, but only by coordination. The prerequisite for any resident’s coordination request is to state the number of the enforcement procedure that the state is conducting against them for illegal construction. A hearing on the petition is scheduled for January 25.
An IDF spokesman’s response: “Contrary to what is claimed, in the area of Firing Zone 918, there is no large-scale operation to confiscate vehicles, but rather routine enforcement activity against unauthorized entry into a firing zone, which is prohibited by law. Enforcement in the area is carried out in accordance with the law in the area against all violators – Israelis and Palestinians. A vehicle owned by an Israeli who entered the firing zone in violation of the law was also confiscated in the area. IDF activity in the area is carried out in accordance with the law and security needs with the aim of maintaining public safety.”
This article is reproduced in its entirety