Amira Hass reports in Haaretz on 8 April 2026:
“Tell me, are you convinced that my son Jadallah is truly not alive?” This is what Safaa Jadallah, the mother of 14-year-old Jadallah Jadallah (Jad to his family) – who was killed by soldiers in the al-Far’a refugee camp in the northeastern West Bank last November, and whose body they took with them – asked me about two weeks ago.
My inquiries did not lead me to the military facility where her son’s body is being held. However, experience shows that in cases like this – when the army says that, in accordance with the decision of the political leadership, it is holding the body of a Palestinian killed by its soldiers – it is not lying.
A video we published in Haaretz showed how, for about 45 minutes, soldiers stood indifferently near the wounded but still living child and offered him no assistance. Since we met at the end of January, Safaa Jadallah has called or written to me every few days or so, expressing her surprise that, despite the media attention, Israel has not returned her son’s body to the family.
At her request, I checked with several people in the West Bank and Israel to see whether they would agree to speak with her about the return of her son’s body. She was disappointed that those who promised to call did not do so. I found myself almost apologizing on their behalf: Israel and Israelis commit so many injustices simultaneously that no single entity is capable of exposing them all, let alone assisting all the people that were directly harmed by them.
She is a mother, and she has every right to expect that her request to bury her son would be heard with compassion. But I felt compelled to temper her expectations, and I wrote to her: the chances that those people could reach the heart of anyone in the Israeli establishment are slim to none.
She was not convinced, and wrote back: “If only those people would speak publicly about my son too.” She still lives in an era when we believed that speaking about injustice could bring about some correction.
Our last correspondence was last Tuesday, March 31, less than 24 hours after the Knesset approved the death penalty law for Palestinians convicted of deadly acts of terrorism by a majority vote. This is a law that deserves every word of condemnation, shock and disgust, along with an urgent petition to the High Court of Justice and scholarly articles analyzing its moral and constitutional flaws. One thing cannot be said about it: that it came like a bolt from the blue.
For years, army commanders, politicians and Israeli society have effectively delegated to every soldier the powers of prosecutor, judge and executioner – as long as he believes the person facing him is Palestinian. There is another delegated authority I have not yet mentioned: that of the victim, or the victim’s representative, who – as the Passover Haggadah puts it – believes that in every generation “they rise up against us to destroy us.” This is the authority to stretch victimhood beyond the boundaries of place and historical context.
We are not even speaking here about pilots or drone operators dropping bombs or launching missiles into houses full of civilians they cannot see. Rather, we are talking about soldiers and police officers deployed throughout the West Bank. If this were not the case – if soldiers and police were acting in violation of strict open-fire regulations guided by the preservation of human life – we would know about it. Many soldiers would have been prosecuted for violating them.
It is permissible to kill an unarmed demonstrator labeled an “inciter,” someone who burns a tire, or someone who throws stones – or is said to have thrown stones or a Molotov cocktail – from a great distance from the soldiers. It is permissible to kill both a child and an adult. The recurring mantra is that the soldier or police officer felt a threat to his life.
This is the explanation that was given for the killing of an entire family traveling in a car to their home in the West Bank village of Tammun. It was also the IDF spokesperson’s response to Haaretz regarding the shooting of Jadallah: the child posed an immediate threat to the soldiers and was shot to remove that threat.
Another video, which we described in the same report on Jadallah and which was broadcast on the BBC, showed that the soldiers shot him while he was fleeing from them. No threat, no danger. We do not know whether he had thrown stones an hour earlier, five minutes earlier, or not at all. But soldiers have been given the authority, and the right, to stretch the meaning of a threat to their lives beyond the constraints of the concrete, immediate moment.
Beyond the bloodlust and vengeance it reflects, the law also stands out for its blatant deviation from the principle of equality before the law. Yet this deviation is not new. The double standard – which the Book of Deuteronomy already forbade – guides daily Israeli actions and shapes Israel’s political psychology.
For example: for about two years, Israel not only devastated the Gaza Strip and its population, but also demanded that the world identify with the justice of its demand to bury the dead whose bodies Hamas and Islamic Jihad continued to hold hostage. Respect for the dead, family suffering, religious obligation, and the fairness required by the rules of war – all were mobilized in a campaign to gain international sympathy.
But none of these principles apply to Israel when it holds hundreds of Palestinian bodies frozen, with the approval of the High Court of Justice, out of pure revenge – including at least 77 minors, among them the child Jadallah. Because the State of Israel enforces unilateralism with precision.
This article is reproduced in its entirety