Baker Zoubi writes in +972 on 8 December 2025:
The ceasefire agreement signed between Israel and Hamas in October brought about the release of nearly 2,000 Palestinian detainees, including some 250 who were serving lengthy or life sentences in Israeli prisons. There were celebrations in Gaza and the West Bank as families were reunited, but also disappointment over Israel’s refusal to free high-profile prisoners like Marwan Barghouti and Ahmad Sa’adat. Yet one group of incarcerated Palestinians was largely absent from the headlines.
Despite also being classified as “security prisoners” — a label Israel applies almost exclusively to Palestinians and which entails much harsher jailing conditions — Palestinian citizens of Israel were excluded from the deal altogether. Around 20 of them have spent more than 35 years behind bars, going back even before the Oslo Accords. Dozens more are serving shorter terms or being held in administrative detention without charge or trial. Israel also continues to withhold the bodies of seven others, most prominently that of Walid Daqqa, who died of cancer in custody last year.
“Based on what came up in the first discussions [between Israel and Hamas] after October 7, and the slogan [often heard in protests in Israel calling for a hostage deal] ‘Everyone for everyone,’ the prisoners expected to be released this time,” Basel Ghattas, a former member of Knesset for the Balad Party and former prisoner himself, told +972. But by the time negotiations concluded, he explained, Palestinian mediators had little leverage left.
“When the Israeli side retracted the release of senior figures like Barghouti, Ibrahim Hamed [commander of Hamas’ military wing in the West Bank], and Sa’adat — even though their names appeared in the agreement signed in Sharm El-Sheikh — the Palestinian side was left with no bargaining cards,” Ghattas continued.
This was hardly the first time that Palestinian prisoners who hold Israeli citizenship were excluded from political agreements. “The pre-Oslo prisoners were supposed to be released in 1993, but [Prime Minister Yitzhak] Rabin refused to do so,” Ghattas recalled. Rabin, he said, instead opted to improve the prisoners’ conditions rather than release them.