Navi Pillay: ‘Israelis, crimes are committed in your name. I beg you. Get on the right side of history’


Navi Pillay. In Israel, her Nobel win prompted an extremely harsh backlash, with critics saying that "Goebbels is applauding from hell." Navi Pillay. In Israel, her Nobel win prompted an extremely harsh backlash, with critics saying that "Goebbels is applauding from hell." Credit: Wikus de Wet / AFP Nobel Peace Prize laureate Navi Pillay, one of the world's leading jurists, is certain that Israel committed genocide in Gaza. And that is precisely why she wants to address Israelis directly. An interview

Nir Hasson writes in Haaretz on 12 November 2026:

Navi Pillay walks into the room barefoot. She is 85 and introduces herself as “an old grandma,” but looks younger than her years. She still remembers in minute detail what everyday life was like under South Africa’s apartheid regime. One incident happened decades ago, when she was a young lawyer.

“We were driving along the highway,” she recalls. “I wanted to use a restroom. There was one for nonwhites and one for whites. I just peeked into the nonwhite one. It was unusable. It’s amazing that the people who owned the establishment even exposed themselves to that level of filth. So I was heading toward the toilets marked ‘whites only,’ and the garage owner was apoplectic with rage. His whole face was red. He was very abusive and chased me out of there. ‘Get out of there!’

“It took me years, but later I thought, he looked worse than I did. My self-esteem was intact, and I went to use the bushes afterward. But what was he doing to himself?”

The anecdote makes Pillay think about us, Israelis.  “I often think of Israelis who’ve been drawn into a situation that the whole world actually condemns. What it must do to them. What must it do to those 17-year-olds who are forcibly trained to kill?”

Pillay, a Nobel Peace Prize laureate and one of the most prominent figures in the realm of international law, speaks with neither anger nor hatred, but with intellectual curiosity. In her various roles, she has spent decades confronting the full range of human atrocities. Israelis, she emphasizes, are no different from other peoples who have revealed their dark sides.

For most of her career, her work had nothing to do with Israel. She was involved in the struggles against apartheid in her homeland, genocide in Rwanda and human rights violations around the globe. She served as a judge at the International Criminal Court and as a judge ad hoc at the International Court of Justice in The Gambia’s case against Myanmar. She was the first nonwhite woman appointed to South Africa’s High Court and served as UN High Commissioner for Human Rights.

But in Israel’s eyes, Pillay is an enemy of the state and the Jewish people. In a report published in September 2025, a commission chaired by her determined that Israel had committed genocide in the Gaza Strip. That made her the world’s most senior jurist to conclude that its actions in Gaza amounted to genocide.

So when she won the Nobel Peace Prize last month, alarm swept through Israel. The country was not mentioned in the Nobel Committee’s citation, but the award, coming a year after the report, lent its findings renewed weight. When her win was announced, Israel’s Foreign Ministry issued an unprecedented response, saying that Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels was “applauding from hell” and that “if there were an award for lies, hatred and blood libels, Navi Pillay wouldn’t just be a contender. She’d be a frontrunner.”

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office called her “a bigot who built her career around inventing and propagating blood libels against the one and only Jewish state.” Israel’s ambassador to the UN, Danny Danon, wondered whether the next step would be to award the prize to Hamas and Al-Qaida terrorists.

Pillay calls the reactions “outrageous.” They are also why she has decided to speak to an Israeli news outlet. “If you’ve been told that that report makes me a Goebbels, read the report yourself. You know, I grew up as a simple, poor girl in South Africa and suffered like all children of color under apartheid. So I know what it feels like to be discriminated against. I fully supported the struggles of Jewish people all over the world. Jews are right when they say there’s a long history of oppression. I expect criticism of my work, but it should be fact-based, not emotional, not racist.”

We meet at her home in Durban, a city where segregation remains palpable even 30 years after apartheid’s collapse. Black residents live in crowded, neglected shantytowns. Across from them are affluent, well-tended neighborhoods whose residents are mostly white, with large homes surrounded by high walls, electric gates and guard dogs.

Pillay does not live in one of those neighborhoods. Her home is in a rundown Muslim neighborhood near the city center, between a Muslim cemetery and an Islamic seminary. It is not a slum, but it is a far cry from the splendor of the white neighborhoods. From her window, you can see shacks and garbage in neighboring yards.

Her younger brother, 77, and her nephew welcome us into the house. She has two daughters, both adopted, one of whom lives in the United States. Her husband, who was imprisoned during apartheid and barred from practicing law, died more than 30 years ago. On the wall of the room where we meet are dozens of awards, honors and degrees from an illustrious 60-year career, including the Nelson Mandela Prize, recognition from the International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association, and praise from Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas.

We get straight to the heart of the matter: the accusation that Israel committed genocide. To establish the crime of crimes, Pillay’s team pointed to the systematic nature of Israel’s actions in Gaza: the mass killing of some 75,000 people; the demolition of almost all homes and infrastructure; the destruction of the conditions essential to the population’s survival, including hospitals, schools, farmland and fishing facilities; and the gap between those actions and the government’s stated military objectives of destroying Hamas and bringing the hostages home.

According to Pillay and her team, the gap between Israel’s stated objectives and its actual conduct can be explained only by “intent” – specifically the intent to destroy Gaza’s inhabitants as a group, “in whole or in part,” as specified in the Genocide Convention’s definition of genocide. Inflammatory statements by Israeli leaders during the war made it easier for the commission to establish intent. The report cited statements by the country’s leaders, including Prime Minister Netanyahu, then-Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and President Isaac Herzog, as evidence of genocidal intent. The commission also recommended prosecuting all three for incitement to genocide.

But the commission’s members stressed that the statements alone would not have sufficed to establish intent, which emerges first and foremost from the actions themselves. In the report’s words: “The pattern of conduct is circumstantial evidence of genocidal intent,” and “genocidal intent was the only reasonable inference that could be drawn from the totality of the evidence.”

The International Court of Justice in The Hague is expected to settle the debate over genocide. It is hearing South Africa’s case against Israel, but a ruling is likely years away. In the meantime, given Pillay’s standing, her report constitutes the most authoritative determination on the subject.

Many Israelis ask how this can be genocide if the Israel Defense Forces evacuated civilians, allowed food into Gaza and helped with a vaccination campaign there. How can genocidal intent be established under those circumstances?

“It’s not a defense to genocide to say, ‘Yeah, but I didn’t kill all of them.’ People raise those arguments very often. It’s very skewed thinking, I think. I don’t think any court would take that seriously. ‘Did you not kill a thousand people here in this case?’ ‘I killed only three.’ The fact that you didn’t kill all of them is covered by the statute. It says destruction in whole or in part of a group. That’s not the intention of the Genocide Convention. The Genocide Convention is about how to prevent genocide. Therefore, failure to prevent is a crime. It’s a crime on its own.”

The Israeli authorities, or the perpetrators named in the report, failed to prevent it, she says.

You say the numbers are not so important because the definition is “the whole group or part of the group.” But the report cites the large death toll as an indicator of genocidal intent. How do those two things fit together?

“There’s no specific requirement in the convention for massive killings, widespread killings. That’s why we say large numbers aren’t a prerequisite. But nevertheless, they’re very, very relevant.  “A genocide judgment by the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda stipulates that a massive number of victims is not necessarily an element of the crime of genocide, though numbers are important in establishing the crime. Even a single act of killing can be a crime under the convention once genocidal intent on the part of the perpetrator is established.

“In Rwanda, it spread throughout the country. But if it had happened only in one part of the country or in some villages inhabited by Tutsis, that would have made no difference. It would still have been genocide.”

If so, why is October 7 not considered genocide?

“The facts we found do not support an allegation of dolus specialis, meaning the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, one of the groups listed in the Genocide Convention. The commission described the acts as war crimes and crimes against humanity, punishable under international law.”

Despite her remarks, the report leaves open the question of whether Hamas committed genocide on October 7, as well as whether the genocide determination should be extended to the West Bank.

Still, you have to establish that Israel intended to destroy the group. Isn’t that a far-reaching conclusion?

“They should let the international media in. Why would the government block international scrutiny? Why did they stop us from investigating? We are a UN body. We follow the rules. We don’t come with any prejudices or bias. Look how long it took us to publish the genocide report. That report alone took us two years. That is how courts operate. They look at each piece of evidence. They look at both sides of the story. We did our best to get the actual evidence. That’s why it took us so long.

“How can you justify withholding urgent medications? How can you justify directly targeting civilians? Ambulance workers, journalists? The other thing that really disturbs me is the torture of people who’d just been picked up and detained. You know, I saw a lot of video footage released by Israeli soldiers. One video showed Israeli soldiers, or their supporters in plain clothes, urinating on [detainees].

“I find all this so disturbing. And I always think that all the Jews I know would never accept that. But do they know about it? Information must be made available to them. It’s their right to know the truth.”

In one section of the report, you write that “Israeli authorities intended to kill as many Palestinians as possible.” Do you really believe that?

“You know, when you use aerial bombing, that’s indiscriminate killing. You don’t care whether children are there, women are there. Nobody should be killed by indiscriminate bombing. We describe the kinds of weapons used. They’re designed to kill a large number of people.”

The Pillay commission’s Oct. 7 report is a detailed document analyzing the massacres and presenting harrowing testimony. In the absence of an Israeli state commission of inquiry, the report is more detailed than any official Israeli investigation to date.  The commission’s legal team continues to stand by that assertion.

“The Israeli authorities […] knew that the means and methods of warfare employed would cause mass deaths of Palestinians, including children,” the team emphasized, citing the report. “Nevertheless, Israeli authorities did not intervene to change the means and methods of warfare employed; on the contrary, the military operations persisted over time and caused even more Palestinian deaths.”

According to the report, a key factor aggravating Israel’s legal position is that Gaza’s civilian population had no way to escape the combat zone. The commission concludes that “the Israeli authorities intended to kill and cause the deaths of the Palestinians in Gaza through the military operations and war strategies employed.”

There is almost no mention of the October 7 massacre throughout the report. When discussing Israel’s explanations, it describes the attacks as “brutal war crimes” that nevertheless “did not pose an existential threat to the State of Israel.” Isn’t that context relevant?

“This report is about genocide and, as the title indicates, it is a factual and legal analysis of whether genocide was committed in Gaza. I expect that defendants in court proceedings, including before the International Court of Justice, will argue that the October 7 attack triggered Israel’s response. But there can be no justification for genocide.”

Pillay points to cases before the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, where defendants sought to justify the genocide against the Tutsis by citing the downing of the Rwandan president’s plane, allegedly by the rebel Rwandan Patriotic Front. The courts rejected that justification, she says.

Israel’s actions followed the trauma of October 7. Wouldn’t other countries have acted as Israel did if their territory had been invaded and hundreds of civilians murdered in a single day?

“Well, Israelis are not especially unique. They’re human beings like everyone else. Everyone roundly condemned the Hamas attack. I particularly remember [the abduction to Gaza of] a 10-month-old child. These are all horrors we condemn. But what did other countries do in response to acts of terrorism? They investigated, arrested the individuals concerned and put them on trial.

“And that is what the world expects Israel to do. Not to go and kill 73,000 civilians. Those are revenge attacks. That’s why it’s totally against international law. What troubles me is that it’s done in the name of Israelis and Jews everywhere. In my view, if they knew the true facts, they would not support this level of retaliation.”

One of the acts you accuse Israel of is preventing births. You base this primarily on a single attack on a fertility clinic. Isn’t that a far-reaching conclusion?

“The fertility clinic was the only such clinic in all of Gaza. It was preserving a very large number of embryos and other reproductive material, as many as 5,000 items. The targeted destruction of the specimens preserved cannot be explained as acts of defense or as an effort to find and kill Hamas fighters – the two reasons given by Israel.”

The IDF Spokesperson’s Unit said in response: “Following an inquiry, the details of the strike are not known to us. The IDF is working to dismantle the Hamas terrorist organization while taking extensive measures to minimize harm to civilians. There are also specific regulations governing the treatment of sensitive sites and objects that require special protection or consideration. The IDF does not deliberately target civilian infrastructure, including IVF clinics.”

To date, only individuals have been convicted of genocide: senior military and government officials from Serbia, Rwanda and Cambodia. No state as a whole has ever been found to have committed genocide. If the International Court of Justice accepts Pillay’s position, Israel could become the first or second country in history to earn that dubious distinction. Myanmar could precede it: The ruling in the case brought by The Gambia, which accuses Myanmar of genocide against the Rohingya minority, is expected on November 19.

Pillay sits on the bench hearing the Myanmar case as a judge ad hoc appointed by The Gambia, just as former Supreme Court President Aharon Barak served as a judge appointed by Israel in South Africa’s case against the country. International law experts believe that a finding that Myanmar committed genocide would increase the likelihood of a similar determination concerning Israel.

Is it fair for Israel to become the first country in history found to have committed genocide? Didn’t other countries deserve similar treatment, such as the United States in the Vietnam War or France in Algeria?

Pillay answers at length. International law, she explains, took time to take shape. When Nazi criminals were tried at Nuremberg, genocide did not yet exist as a distinct criminal offense. “It was the Jewish experience that gave rise, after the Nuremberg trials, to an international judicial system,” she says.

The criteria for the crime were defined only when the Genocide Convention was signed in 1948. The Cold War then froze the development of international law for decades. It was only in 1993, when the UN Security Council moved to establish a tribunal to address the war in the Balkans, that genocide proceedings began. The first international conviction came in 1998, handed down by a panel on which Pillay herself sat.

“I’ve been approached by civil society groups in very many countries saying, ‘What about us? What happened to us was genocide,'” Pillay says. “When it comes to judicial reasoning, we don’t just adopt a flowery term. We look for the evidence. We check it and see whether the actions taken against the people indicate that intention. Then we look for the intention. Where’s the evidence for it? We look at the orders given to the military, the speeches, the hate speech by leaders. That’s what we did in the Rwandan case.”

The apartheid regime you fought against and the Israeli government maintained close ties throughout the 1970s and ’80s. Could that have left you prejudiced against Israel?

“I know I have no preconceived notions of hating Israel. Why would I hate the whole country? I name the perpetrators, who happen to be its leaders. Yes, it’s true that there was very close contact and cooperation between the Israeli government at the time and the South African apartheid government. How do I know this? I acted for so many people who were detained and tortured.

“I had a lot of dealings with the security police at the time, asking for information about my clients. I don’t know whether they were boasting or speaking the truth. They said, ‘Guess who trained us and who’s given us all these weapons, even the instruments to extract confessions.’ And they named Mossad and the CIA. But I didn’t hold that against the people of Israel, because it was certain individuals, certain politicians who did that, not the people themselves.”

Fifteen years ago, she adds, the Israeli government invited her on an official visit. “I went to Sderot, where rockets fired from Gaza were falling, and visited the underground shelters. That’s where the little children were being taught. They couldn’t come out to play. And I saw videos of Israeli children shuddering with fright each time these heavy rockets fell on the roof. The parents I saw were all that close to tears. And I understood that.”

In the report, she says, “there isn’t a whisper that we’re blaming Jewish people for this. Absolutely not. We set out the evidence and point to three individuals [Netanyahu, Gallant and Herzog]. We recommended that all three be investigated and prosecuted. So it’s false to say the whole report is against the Jewish community.”

Pillay during the struggle against apartheid. She succeeded in securing the right of political prisoners, including Nelson Mandela, to meet with lawyers.

Last month, when the chair of the Norwegian Nobel Committee announced the prizewinner, he addressed Pillay live on air and asked her to answer her phone. The committee, he said, had been unable to reach her to tell her she had won.

Pillay had switched off her phone because she was attending a conference of international jurists in Courtroom 600 in Nuremberg, the very room where the leaders of the Nazi regime were tried. And so the whole world learned she had won the Nobel before she did. One of the conference organizers approached her and asked her to step outside for a few minutes, she recalls. “I meekly tiptoed out of the room. When we got out, he and the legal officer looked at each other. They said to each other, ‘Who’s going to tell her?’

“What was I to think? I expected the worst, that something had happened to my children. And then he said, ‘I have good news for you.'”

At first, she refused to believe it. Only when they showed her the announcement on television was she convinced. By the time she returned to the courtroom, word had spread, and everyone rose to their feet and applauded. “If you clap a little bit more, I may share this prize with Trump,” she said, to laughter from the audience. Referring to praise for her courage after the Gaza report, she asked: “Why would you need courage to speak the truth?”

Pillay was born in 1941 into a rigid system of racial segregation that became the apartheid regime seven years later. Her grandparents, of Tamil descent, were brought from India by the British to work on sugar plantations. One of them lost both arms in a workplace accident. Her father was a bus driver, and she grew up in a poor Durban neighborhood that was then home to the Indian community.

Apartheid and the struggle against it shaped her worldview. “As a child, you notice first the acts of discrimination that affect you,” she recalls. “You go to a park and you’re not allowed to play on the swings. Durban is known for its beaches, but they were all declared for whites only.”

“Your parents are so scared of breaking the law, terrified that the police will come and do something,” she says. “I was aware that my parents were frightened. Teachers were fired if they even talked about an article in the newspaper. So if the adults are frightened, it affects children. Only gradually did we discover what was going on.  “We would go Christmas shopping once a year. We had very few coins in our hands, but we went all the way into the city, to the white area, in awe. As we stood at the sweet counter waiting to buy some sweets, the assistants would only serve whites. Only when there was no white person left in the line would they turn to us.”

She first entered a courtroom at age 5, when she testified about being robbed. The money was not recovered, but the robber was convicted. Pillay has said that the realization that the law existed, and that she could use it, stayed with her. A few years later, she began telling people at school that she wanted to become a lawyer. “The teacher ridiculed me,” she says. She stood out as a brilliant student, and at 15 won an essay prize from the Jewish Women’s Association. She says she was surprised that the association had opened the competition to nonwhite schools.

She was able to enroll at university thanks to a collection organized by people in her neighborhood to pay for her studies. Segregation continued in higher education, too. Nonwhite students attended classes in shifts on the second floor of a potato warehouse.

After completing her law degree, she struggled to find work. Law firms explained that a nonwhite woman could not possibly give instructions to a white secretary. So she opened her own practice and began representing opponents of the regime and ordinary victims of the system, such as fishermen who crossed a whites-only beach. Like many who fought apartheid, she remembers fondly the Jewish activists and lawyers who stood alongside Black South Africans.

She also represented her husband, who was arrested and held in solitary confinement after donating a small sum to a banned anti-apartheid organization. She fought torture and campaigned for prisoners’ rights, even visiting the notorious prison on Robben Island, where Nelson Mandela was held. In one of her most significant legal battles, she secured the right of political prisoners, including Mandela, to meet with lawyers.

In apartheid’s final years, Pillay gained admission to Harvard Law School, breaking another glass ceiling along the way: She became the first South African to earn a doctorate in law from the elite university.

Pillay did not join Mandela’s party, the African National Congress, but the Unity Movement, which stood further to the left and demanded not only the abolition of apartheid but also the redistribution of land. “I wish we’d done that,” she says. “We wouldn’t have the problems we have today.”

Despite their ideological differences, after apartheid fell, Mandela appointed Pillay a judge on the country’s High Court. She thus became the first nonwhite woman to hold the position.

Shortly afterward, she was appointed a judge at the international tribunal established to prosecute the perpetrators of the Rwandan genocide. In that role, she confronted the horrors of the genocide against the Tutsis and helped deliver two landmark rulings. The first established that rape and sexual assault were not merely acts accompanying genocide but could themselves constitute acts of genocide intended to “destroy the group,” as defined in the Genocide Convention. The ruling is considered a breakthrough for women in conflict zones. The second concerned journalists’ role in inciting genocide. Pillay was on the panel of judges that convicted a media editor who had systematically incited genocide.

In 2008, Pillay was appointed UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, and in 2011 she visited Israel. In a sequence of events that seems almost unimaginable today, she was received by President Shimon Peres at his official residence, met with Defense Minister Ehud Barak and senior Justice and Foreign Ministry officials, and visited Yad Vashem. She was the last high commissioner to visit Israel. In subsequent years, Israel adopted a policy of boycotting the office, and an ever-widening gulf opened between the country and international law.

The turning point in the failed romance between Pillay and Israel came in 2021, when, following that year’s Gaza war and the events surrounding it, the UN decided to appoint a special commission of inquiry into Israel and Palestine. Pillay was appointed its chair, putting her on a collision course with Israel.

The commission played a significant role in the deterioration of Israel’s international standing. In a series of reports, it sharply criticized the occupation and violations of Palestinians’ human rights. In 2022, it recommended that the General Assembly ask the International Court of Justice for an advisory opinion on the legality of the occupation. The opinion, delivered a year and a half later, was scathing and unequivocal: Israel was violating international law, and its control over the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem was unlawful. Adopted by the General Assembly, the opinion became a central legal argument in initiatives to boycott Israel, including the latest European initiative to ban settlement products.

Israel maintains that Pillay is spearheading discriminatory treatment of Israel by the UN and the international legal system. For example, the commission she chaired is the only one of its kind whose mandate does not require periodic renewal. Its mandate allows it to investigate everything that takes place, not only in the occupied territories but also within sovereign Israel, and to trace the conflict back to its roots.

Pillay rejects these claims. She says they stem from a failure to understand just how exceptional Israel’s situation is from the perspective of international law. “There were two countries under special scrutiny before the Human Rights Council: apartheid South Africa and Israel over its occupation,” she says. “Apartheid ended, so South Africa came off the radar. Israel remained because the occupation has not ended.”

In September 2023, the commission published its report on the events surrounding the 2021 Gaza war, sharply criticizing the IDF and police for their use of force against Palestinian demonstrators. The report also accused both Israel and Hamas of war crimes: Israel for harming civilians in Gaza, and Hamas for indiscriminate rocket fire.

After that report, Pillay intended to step down. But following the October 7 attack, she decided to stay. She was among the first senior UN figures to condemn Hamas, doing so a few days after the attack. In the summer of 2024, the commission she chaired published two reports: the first on the events of October 7, and the second on the war in Gaza.

The October 7 report is a detailed document analyzing the massacres at the various sites and presenting harrowing testimony, including accounts of sexual assault. Indeed, in the absence of an Israeli state commission of inquiry, Pillay’s report is more detailed than any official Israeli investigation to date. The commission found that Hamas had committed a long list of war crimes and crimes against humanity, including murder, torture, abduction and abuse of bodies, and identified a recurring pattern of sexual violence. It also found that the Israeli authorities had failed to protect civilians and that the implementation of the Hannibal Directive – an Israeli military protocol intended to prevent soldiers’ capture, even at the risk of their lives – had caused the deaths of at least 14 civilians.

Pillay: “We wanted the hostages returned immediately, and proper investigations and prosecutions. We named individuals who should be charged. In the course of our work, we investigated sexual violence.” The commission was fully aware that such violence had occurred, she notes. “We investigated it and found evidence that Hamas had sexually violated women, in some cases raped them.

“We were denied access to them, so we never got to speak to them ourselves. As head of that commission, I always said that was wrong. Israelis need justice like anybody else, and here they were being prevented from speaking about what happened to them.”

Israel’s Health Ministry did indeed issue a specific directive instructing doctors and medical staff not to provide the commission with information about October 7 victims.

Four days after publishing the October 7 report, the commission released a report on Israel’s actions in Gaza, finding that Israel was committing war crimes and crimes against humanity. From that point onward, Pillay’s reports grew increasingly severe as the war intensified and Gaza’s humanitarian situation deteriorated. The latest report, which concluded that Israel was committing genocide, was published, as noted, in September 2025.

Pillay announced her departure from the commission before the report was published. She emphatically denies rumors that she stepped down to avoid U.S. sanctions that could prevent her from entering the United States, where her daughter lives. “That is such a lie. It’s a lie,” she says, adding that she is amazed that it could reach so many people.

From the outset, she says, she had intended to serve on the commission for no more than two or three years. “And then October 7 happened. I could not in all conscience step down. Where in the world do you have an 85-year-old running around working that hard?”

Just hours after you were awarded the prize, the Trump administration announced further sanctions against the International Criminal Court. Do you consider the possibility that you, too, will eventually face sanctions?

“Yes, I can see that. The person who succeeded me [Indian jurist Srinivasan Muralidhar] was denied a visa to go to the United States and deliver his report to the General Assembly.”

Do you think Netanyahu will actually stand trial before an international court?

“I believe that International Criminal Court warrants must be acted upon by the states of the world. I admit that justice is a slow process. We know that Israel’s own pursuit of high-level suspects in Nazi-era crimes succeeded many years after the crimes were committed.”

Many people in Israel lost hope that anything could change after what happened on October 7. Since then, they have seen no way out. Is there anything you would say to them?

“We went through that. I know the feeling. I didn’t think I’d see change in my lifetime. Change came through negotiations, which we all hated. We hated Mandela for selling us out, because our struggle was all or nothing. We hated that de Klerk got half the Nobel Prize. Why? He’s a perpetrator. Why give it to him?

“But now I’m thinking, if he hadn’t signed the negotiated agreement, where would we be today? So I value what Mandela did. It took a lot of courage on his part because people opposed him, especially young people. When he first came out, he came here to Durban and went to the local university. The students said to him, ‘What are you doing wearing a suit, wearing white man’s clothing?’ And that’s why he changed into those shirts that are now called Mandela shirts.”

Is there a message you would like to convey to Israelis?

“I would say to Israelis: Crimes are being committed in your name. Wouldn’t you like to be on the right side of history? People all over the world will always support you and sympathize with what happened in the Holocaust. Your leaders are abusing their power. They’re acting without giving the population a true picture of their actions, and without showing Israelis what’s happening in international forums. So I would plead with them to get onto the right side of history.

“Look at the change in South Africa. I’m not saying we’re a wonderful example. No, we’re still in the process of realizing our wishes. But we averted terrible violence here. And I’m very, very happy that young people are not forced to train as soldiers to kill other people. I would worry about that if I were a parent in Israel.”

Your work has exposed you to so many atrocities. You see the worst sides of humanity. How does that affect you?

“I used to tell people I’d lost my smile. You don’t see judges smiling. Well, we’ve seen the worst, you know, and you never forget. You never forget. I still recall some of the incidents we saw on video,” she says of Gaza.

“I saw many atrocities. In South Africa, children who had done drawings were detained, some as young as 8. I saw an affidavit from the war in Yugoslavia. A woman from Croatia said she worked with two Serbian men, all three of them doctors. They worked together in the same ward for 12 years. Suddenly, one day, they turned around and raped her.”

Pillay recalls the story of a family in Rwanda whose neighbors stole their cow one day. “Witnesses said, ‘They killed it in front of us, roasted the meat and ate it.’ And you might think, ‘Well, that’s a small thing.’ It’s not. It’s a breakdown of the unwritten laws.” Later, she says, those same neighbors, whom the family had known for years, “came over and raped the girls in the house, two daughters in front of the mother. One of the people we convicted was the head of the Seventh-day Adventist Church. The killings took place in his church as people rushed there for refuge. This man cooperated with the killers, who closed the doors and killed them there, right in front of the altar.

“I often wondered, listening to accounts of the Rwandan genocide, would I behave like that? Something happens, and you join the killing fervor. I used to sit and think, would I behave like that amid that frenzy? Everybody’s killing, so you join in.”

And what do you tell yourself?

“I felt my own values and culture would protect me.”

This article is reproduced in its entirety

© Copyright JFJFP 2026