Jack Khoury wwrites in Haaretz on 25 December 2025:
What is brewing in the West Bank these days is not just another “spat of clashes,” nor some seasonal event having to do with the autumn olive harvest season, nor some local outburst of violence that can be contained or framed as a local problem. This is a different, much more dangerous reality: one that derives from policy. This policy is clear and ongoing. It is intended to change facts on the ground, so that West Bank annexation does not remain some political statement about the future, but becomes daily action grounded in the present.
The old claim by Israel’s defense establishment, that each such spat of violence is a temporary thing that arises mainly during “sensitive” periods such as the olive harvest, has turned into hot air. The olive harvest is long over and violence has only intensified since then. Attacks on Palestinian shepherds, farmers, families and defenseless civilians are ceaseless. The attackers are not using just sticks and stones but firearms, pepper spray, vandalizing and setting property on fire. People are getting hurt, sheep are getting slaughtered, trees are being uprooted. Anything Palestinian is considered fair game.
The events of the last few days clearly demonstrate the severity of West Bank violence, which has now reached a new high: On Monday, five Israelis stormed a family home in the village of Samu, in the South Hebron Hills. They wounded a mother and her three children and even abused sheep belonging to the family.
Harming Palestinians’ livestock has also long become commonplace, a repeating pattern. The shooting of Palestinians near the settlement of Anatot on Sunday, which ended with critically wounded people, also reflects a larger reality – military weapons used carelessly against Palestinian civilians, sometimes by settlers rather than soldiers. The official Israeli version will always frame this as a “clash” and “stone throwing” that will justify the outcome.
Herein lies the problem: The systematic effort by the defense establishment and the political echelon, framing the violence as actions of “a small handful,” “hilltop youth” or “fanatical youngsters” who do not represent the settlers, is misleading. Not because there are no extremists, but because this extremism operates as part of a policy-led system. The political-defense establishment turns a blind eye, sometimes even providing covert aid.
If there is any deterrence in the West Bank, it is applied to Palestinians only. Violent settlers do not experience it as some real threat. The military, police and security services are present on the ground, but their presence does not protect Palestinians. On the contrary: In many cases it inspired the attackers with a sense of immunity. When a Palestinian picks up a weapon, he becomes an immediate target. However, when an armed settlers hurts Palestinians – the incident is allowed to blow over and is investigated lazily, or closed without an indictment. This is not anarchy. This is a clear distinction between those protected by the systems and those that remain completely exposed.
And in this reality, the Palestinian Authority has become irrelevant. Its police officers and members of its security forces are unable, and sometimes scared, to go near areas of friction. Local attempts to set up security squads in the villages fail due to arrests and military violence, and mainly because there is no real way to face off armed settlers who enjoy immunity. The message to Palestinians is clear: Nobody is protecting you.
In step with the violence, government policy is also moving forward. Cabinet approval for the legalization of 19 new outposts – following the legalization of dozens such outposts in recent years – and the investment of tens of billions of shekels in West Bank infrastructure are not technical steps. They are additional aspects of that same move. This is how annexation is implemented in practice, without being officially declared, using the standard, insurmountable argument: security.
Here, the international powers enter the picture. They used to be thought of as beneficial, providing protection for Palestinians, but they too have failed, judging by results. Neither the United Nations (and its agencies), nor the International Court of Justice, nor enlightened Europe, nor powerful China have been helping West Bank residents. There is also no point in trusting Arab countries. Don’t believe it? Just ask West Bank Palestinians.
In light of the ongoing disappointment, there remains U.S. president Donald Trump. If he still wishes to convince himself that there is no annexation in the West Bank and that he had achieved peace in the Middle East, unparalleled in 3,000 years – he had better take a look at what has been taking place. Let him see the actions rather than read the declarations.
The war in Gaza may have been ceased – even if its inhabitants will be dealing with its destructive outcomes for many years to come – but another, quieter and equally destructive war is brewing in the West Bank. Anybody seeking peace cannot ignore this reality and cannot characterize the West Bank as a stable region. Peace is not built on daily violence, gradual expulsion and depriving an entire population of protection. That is the truth. And in the West Bank, that has long been unconcealable.
This article is reproduced in its entirety