Hadeel Abu Salih writes in Haaretz on 12 May 2026:
The body of Khaled Hassan was held by the state for eight months. For eight months, his family lived in uncertainty, and was unable to part from him and bury him, or even to know what exactly happened to him. Only after the filing of an urgent petition, which was first brought to court last week, did the police report that it intended to release his body. This case isn’t a specific mishap; it’s a reflection of a broader and more disturbing policy: holding bodies as a tool of control and punishment, while emptying the rule of law of any genuine content.
Already on the day of the incident, the police hastened to publish a report to the effect that “two terrorists were killed.” In other words, the fate of Hassan was sealed even before any investigation began, before the circumstances of the incident were examined and before his family was given the most basic opportunity to understand what happened. The immediate public declaration wasn’t a neutral description of facts but an unequivocal declaration of guilt and dangerousness, which was made without an investigation, without due process and without evidence open to public perusal.
Ultimately, the state admitted Hassan wasn’t suspected of anything, and the High Court reprimanded its representatives, even if belatedly, when it noted the authorities had held the body of someone who had done no wrong.
Even within the security logic the state is trying to promote, it’s hard to ignore the basic question: Why was the lethal option chosen in the first place? According to the state’s own version, Hassan was behind another man suspected of being a terror activist, and the police had difficulty distinguishing between them. In that case, how was the decision made within seconds to kill both instead of detaining them? How has killing become an almost automatic mode of action, even where there’s a reasonable possibility to delay or detain? The total immunity the system grants to soldiers and policemen who open fire in violation of the law costs human lives, time after time.
These questions only became more acute in light of the state’s conduct after the killing. For eight months, the state claimed it was “clarifying” whether it was “the body of a terrorist.” At the same time, it was decided not to perform an autopsy, although that is a main tool for clarifying the circumstances of death, and we even requested it be performed from the moment the petition was filed. Nor was a criminal probe opened. In other words, the state claimed it wanted to clarify the truth, but, in effect, ensured there would be no real tools to make it possible to do so.
During the entire period, the petition to return the body remained pending before the High Court. Despite the urgency, the court refrained for months from ordering a hearing, and approved six requests by the state to extend submission of its first response. This is not just bureaucratic foot-dragging. When the courts enable the authorities to drag out processes for months in cases involving the dignity of the deceased, the honor of the family and serious complaints regarding the use of lethal force, they aren’t operating in a neutral manner. The postponement itself becomes part of the system that causes harm.
The case of Hassan isn’t unusual. The body of Mu’aman Abu-Riash, a man from Ramle who was killed by the army in Qalqilyah, was held for months with the claim that a “clarification of facts” was being conducted to check whether he was a terrorist. In this case too, the government, in a court hearing, couldn’t present a foundation that justified the shooting.
A State Prosecutor’s Office representative made do with general and vague claims that stones were being thrown at police in the area, without mentioning a time, without pointing to any involvement of Abu-Riash and without explaining how this justifies his killing or continuing to hold his body. Only after the court ordered the government to accelerate the clarification process and to update during a specific time frame did the state report its intention to release the body.
These two cases expose a difficult situation: the death of Palestinians is quickly classified as part of “prevention of terror,” which automatically turns every Palestinian into a potential terrorist, unless his family or civil society organizations prove otherwise. Clarification of the facts, if it takes place at all, is repeatedly postponed, and throughout this time, families are suspended between uncertainty, hope and bereavement.
Holding bodies isn’t only an administrative or security issue; it’s a profound blow to human dignity, to the right to burial and to the basic right of a family to know the fate of its loved one. A society that accepts a situation in which families must fight for months to bury their loved ones is one that has crossed the boundary between law enforcement and institutionalized abuse.
The writer is a lawyer in the department for political and civil rights in Adalah – The Legal Center for Minority Rights in Israel.
This article is reproduced in its entirety