Israeli police didn’t investigate the settler incident but still concluded the reverse of what happened


Dozens of settlers, some of them armed, raided the village of Deir Jarir, stealing sheep and beating their owners, including an 81-year-old shepherd. The police never investigated the incident, but ruled that the report was a 'serious and deliberate distortion of reality' Sadeq Farahneh and his grandson who has the same name. both wounded by settlers, September 2025

Gideon Levy reports in Haaretz on 26 September 2025:

A sheep’s carcass lay on the hay-strewn floor of the pen. It rested on its side, its brown head slumped and wounded, its udders full of milk. The dead sheep was all that remained this week of the flock once kept by brothers Jihad and Sharif al-Muho, which they say numbered 230 animals.

Human rights group B’Tselem field researcher Mohammad Romaneh, who investigated the theft, said that eyewitnesses in the village reported a smaller figure – about 120 sheep. Either way, by Monday, the day after the raid, the spacious pen stood empty and silent. The large iron gate was broken and tossed aside.

The brothers say that settlers killed the sheep by striking its head with an iron rod after it refused to leave the pen. The ewe had recently given birth and wouldn’t abandon her lambs, so the settlers brutally killed her, according to the brothers. The rest of the flock, they managed to force out and steal.

Deir Jarir, a village of about 6,000 residents in the Ramallah district, lies on the mountain ridge at the edge of the Jordan Valley. The road to the village passes through the affluent town of Taibeh, which looks far more well-kept than the Israeli city with the same name. Jihad al-Muho, a 44-year-old farmer, and his brother Sharif, 48, a Palestinian Authority police officer, own 52 dunams (around 13 acres) of olive trees and grazing land that they can no longer approach. The two describe the hardships their village endures under the threat of settlers, which have greatly intensified since October 7 and even more so in recent months, as the last restraints on the settlers have been removed. In the past four months alone, no fewer than eight outposts have been established on the hills overlooking Deir Jarir, choking it from all sides, and their residents are violent.

The descriptions are the same ones now heard across the West Bank: A tiny outpost, a hut or two, is established; thousands of surrounding dunams are taken over, including olive groves, fields and grazing lands, with their owners no longer able to approach them; then come violent assaults, property arson and theft of livestock. At times the attacks also end in death: in Deir Jarir, three residents – two men and a woman – have been killed since the outbreak of the war in attacks often carried out jointly by the army and settlers. The settlers invade and attack, the army arrives and protects the violent intruders with gunfire. Sometimes the settlers themselves shoot and kill. The most recent casualty in the village was killed on September 13, when three young men tried to place stones to block an illegal road that settlers had paved on village land. Mohammad Alawi, 20, was killed by gunfire from either the army or the settlers, or settlers in uniform.

This past Sunday, around 9 A.M., five settlers appeared on the eastern outskirts of the village, accompanied by several sheep. First, they attacked the neighbor of the al-Muho brothers, 81-year-old shepherd Sadeq Farahneh, along with his son and grandson, and stole their flock (more on them later) and then approached the gate of the al-Muho brothers’ pen.

The family tried to drive the intruders away by throwing stones, prompting the settlers to call for reinforcement. Help arrived quickly: about 30 to 40 settlers, some masked, roughly 20 of them armed with M16 rifles, along with two army jeeps. They broke the iron gate of the pen, which is located near the family homes, and the settlers entered.

Under the protection of the army, which observed from about 100 meters away without intervening, the settlers removed the brothers’ sheep and hurried to mark them. B’Tselem investigator Romaneh says this is a well-known settler method: They immediately mark the stolen sheep as if they were theirs and fold them into their own flock. Sometimes they even claim that Palestinians stole their sheep after marking them. As we will see, the police quickly adopt the settlers’ version without investigating. A police patrol arrived at the scene but according to residents, they merely watched from the side.

Meanwhile one of the brothers, Jihad, tried to get his children to safety inside the house. He says the settlers began firing in his direction. They didn’t hit him and may have only fired into the air. About 45 minutes later, the settlers’ convoy departed with their loot. The incident didn’t come as a surprise. Four days earlier, several settlers arrived on two all-terrain vehicles, apparently to gather intelligence. They drove around the area and then left.

Under the protection of the army, the settlers removed the brothers’ sheep and hurried to mark them. This is a well-known settler method: They mark the stolen sheep and fold them into their own flock.
This Monday, the day after the sheep raid, the al-Muho brothers’ home was in mourning. The two brothers sat with somber faces in the courtyard, while dozens of residents came to offer condolences and lift their spirits. They asked not to be photographed.

The brothers didn’t bother filing a complaint with the police, saying it would be pointless. Sharif explained: “If I tried to steal your watch and someone saw it and said you stole it from me, there’s no way I could get it back. If I go to the police, they’ll say I stole it, because the settlers are the ones in power here.” He could not have known how accurate his words would prove.

This week, the Israel Police spokesperson responded to Haaretz regarding the claim that officers did nothing: “The claims in your inquiry constitute a serious and deliberate distortion of reality. In fact, an Israeli shepherd was violently attacked by masked Palestinians who stole 70 of his sheep. Police and Israel Defense Forces troops acted immediately, entered the village, located the flock, and returned it to its owners. Any attempt to portray the event as the police ‘accompanying a settler theft’ is a complete reversal of the facts, severely undermines journalistic credibility and deliberately misleads the public.”

The police response is astonishing. How do they know it was the Palestinians who stole the sheep if they didn’t bother to conduct an investigation or question them? And if the al-Muho brothers had taken the settlers’ sheep, why didn’t the police arrest them immediately? It turns out that the police’s cooperation with violent settlers also includes spreading falsehoods and shielding criminal acts.

A comment from the IDF spokesperson had not been received by the time of publication.

On Monday at 3 A.M., three ATVs appeared again and, after a noisy round, left. The brothers have no idea why they came, but Sharif says the settlers never act randomly: “Everything is planned in coordination with the army. I’m not in their heads, and I don’t know what they’re plotting now, but their goal is clear – to keep us from reaching our lands, which is why they target shepherds and farmers. And they do it effectively.”

About a month ago, they found a camera hidden in the brush on their land. They’re convinced the settlers placed it there to alert them every time the farmers try to reach their fields. This year, they already know, they won’t be able to harvest their olives when the season begins in the coming days. Last year, they managed to reach roughly a third of their trees. Sharif said, “All that’s left for us is to die. There’s no point in living. If your flock is stolen, your road blocked, your home destroyed and your children arrested – there is no reason to live.”

In his spacious home in the center of the village, far from the site of the incident, Sadeq Farahneh, the shepherd, lies on the sofa in the living room, asking that we not shake his hand because he’s in pain. Both of his hands are bandaged, as is the head of his grandson, 23, who shares his name. The grandson has 10 stitches in his head, and Sadeq’s arm is broken and still needs surgery. During the incident, Sadeq was struck by settlers wielding clubs until he fell to the ground. Together with his 41-year-old son, Khairy, they have about 100 sheep. Thirty-five of them did not go out to pasture that day, and were stolen by settlers. According to the son, before stealing the sheep, the settlers fed their own animals with the feed stored in the pen.

Khairy says the settlers attacked his father for no reason. After he fell to the ground, they left him and turned their attention to his grandson, who had arrived in the meantime. A pipe and a cup of dark tea sit beside Sadeq’s bed. He is certain that if his son and grandson had not been there, he would have died.

This article is reproduced in its entirety

© Copyright JFJFP 2026