Chaim Levinson writes in Haaretz on 26 October 2025:
One month has passed since U.S. President Donald Trump unveiled his 20-point plan for peace in the Gaza Strip. U.S. Army officers have printed out his 20 commandments on high-quality posterboard and placed them in the Civil-Military Coordination Center now opening in Kiryat Gat. The Israeli hostages who were held in Gaza have been brought back home. And now, all other issues that were on the table are either stuck in limbo or have been erased from the agenda.
When the plan was launched, the thinking in Washington was that the so-called “Board of Peace,” which was supposed to take over Gaza’s administration, would be set up within a month. After a week packed with diplomatic discussions in Israel by special envoy Steve Witkoff, Trump’s son-in-law Jared Kushner, Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, it is clear that the board’s establishment is still far off.
Consequently, the formation of an international stabilization force to fight Hamas has been postponed indefinitely, and doubts are beginning to arise as to whether it will ever exist at all.
The root of the problem lay in the way Trump’s plan was unveiled. It was half-baked, lacking many details, and it was shoved down both Hamas’ and Israel’s throats as if they were geese to be fattened.
The other problem is Hamas. The Board of Peace hasn’t been formed, because no country has any interest in committing money to Gaza when it doesn’t know what will become of the territory. And it’s impossible to know that as long as Hamas hasn’t decided what role it wants to play in Gaza and whether it plans to hold on to its weapons or disarm.
The Americans’ idea – that an Arab-Muslim force would fight Hamas, plain and simple – currently has no basis in reality. Foreign countries are willing to send peacekeeping troops, a kind of enhanced police force that would demonstrate a presence and hand out flowers, candy and maybe a few traffic tickets. But that’s it. They have no intention of going tunnel to tunnel and house to house (at least in those houses that remain) or waging street battles with Hamas. Hamas is still popular in the Arab street. And no Arab or Muslim country wants to be seen as an agent of Western imperialism, suppressing heroes of the Islamic nation.
Indonesia, which promised thousands of soldiers, has turned out to be a weak reed. The country’s president, Prabowo Subianto, is viewed as an unstable person who could declare nuclear war on Israel and announce a peace deal with it on the very same day. Egypt doesn’t want to get more deeply embroiled in Gaza. The United Arab Emirates is in, but it has limited manpower to contribute.
In a lightning visit to Doha on Sunday, Trump spoke about sending Qatari troops to Gaza. That’s a classic example of his lack of mastery of the details. Qatar has no people. Its police force is essentially a model of the police force Trump’s plan envisions for Gaza: Qatar itself imports police officers from Kenya, who are supervised by local senior officials, because of the sparseness of the actual Qatari population in the peninsula.
Talks on how to solve this problem are taking place in Cairo. There, behind the scenes, discussions are being held among Egypt, Hamas, the Palestinian Authority and other Arab states, with the goal of reaching a mutually agreeable plan for implementing the second stage of the cease-fire deal.
Clearly, Hamas will be required to “lay down its weapons.” The question, of course, is which weapons, and what it will receive in exchange. Hamas has no intention of opening paddleboarding clubs in Trump’s new Gaza Riviera; it plans to run Gaza from behind the scenes.
The Egyptians hope Hamas will take a big step back, hand over its weapons of its own accord, reconcile with the Palestinian Authority, and invite its “Arab brothers” to rebuild Gaza for everyone’s sake. But to the best of my knowledge, the Cairo talks are far from reaching a consensus.
What is clear is that no matter what is agreed on in Cairo regarding how the deal’s second stage will be run, it will be unacceptable to Israel. The maximum Hamas is willing to give doesn’t even come close to the minimum Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is willing to swallow. And that’s doubly true for far-right ministers like Bezalel Smotrich and Orit Strock, who are breathing down his neck and reminding him that Hamas is alive and kicking and controlling territory in Gaza.
Meanwhile, the Americans understand that Israel would be happy to blow up the cease-fire agreement. But as they promised in a personal meeting with senior Hamas official Khalil al-Hayya, they gave guarantees to the Arab states that this wouldn’t happen.
Trump’s unusual refueling stop in Doha gave him another opportunity to show his boundless love for Qatar’s emir and his swollen purse by taking the rare step of hosting a foreign leader on Air Force One. Qatar’s interests in this game are clear. Trump got lots of applause when he spoke in the Knesset, but he’s getting (metaphoric) suitcases full of gold from Qatar.
U.S. Vice President JD Vance told Israel that even the most minimal Israeli troop movement in Gaza would require advance notice to Washington, meaning there’s an American veto. America has backed Hamas on the issue of returning the dead hostages, and is giving it more time to hand over the remaining bodies. On Sunday, under American pressure, the Egyptian technical team entered Gaza to help search for the bodies.
Trump, who is visiting Asia, said on social media that he will monitor developments. This week, we will presumably see additional bodies returned.
The United States is monitoring it all from the base it established in Kiryat Gat, which technically serves as a foreign intelligence outpost on Israeli soil. Its main purpose is to monitor all IDF activity in the Gaza Strip, to ensure Israel does not violate the cease-fire.
In the longer term, Washington is still deliberating over its next steps. On the one hand, it is trying to build up various international coalitions. Meanwhile, a proposal has surfaced to allow evangelical NGOs, with the support of the IDF, to begin setting up temporary infrastructures in Rafah, including caravans, tents, schools and even job opportunities, to show Gazans that Hamas is not the ultimate ruler, and that the Strip can recover without it.
For now, however, the plan lacks any funding, and eventually, the burden will most likely fall on Israel.
This article is reproduced in its entirety