A knife in the back’: Bedouin villagers in Israel given 90 days to evacuate – and nowhere to go


The High Court rejected the appeal of residents of the unrecognized village of Ras Jrabah, ordering them off land they have lived on since before Israel's founding to make way for Dimona's expansion. The court also denied their request to relocate into the city, backing the state's position that Bedouin cannot receive plots in Jewish communities A child in the Bedouin village of Ras Jrabah, November 2025

Eden Solomon reports in Haaretz on 24 November 2025:

The scene is a familiar one in the Negev: Representatives from the Regional Council of Unrecognized Villages, the Steering Committee, the NGO Adalah, activists and residents crowd into an emergency meeting, weighed down by a sense of déjà vu. Another Bedouin village, with no real housing alternative, is facing demolition. This time the deadline is 90 days. Following the High Court’s ruling, everyone understands that the chances of stopping the move are negligible, and they must now prepare for the day of destruction.

The village in question is Ras Jrabah, east of Dimona. Six years of legal battle came to an end recently with the outcome everyone feared: the High Court denied the residents’ appeal, rejected their demand to formalize the status of their village, and dismissed their hope of being integrated into a new Jewish neighborhood planned on lands their families have lived on for generations.

Hours before the emergency meeting, Sheikh Freij Alhwashla sits in his shig, which has become a pilgrimage site for people from villages across the region. He is about 93, the oldest and best-known resident of Ras Jrabah. No one knows his exact age – births were not carefully documented at the time – but he clearly remembers the British Mandate and the establishment of Dimona in 1955. He himself worked nearly three decades as a gardener for the Dimona municipality, planting many of the city’s first trees.

“We’ve been on our land since the time of the Ottomans and the British; Dimona was built partly on our lands,” he says. “The first residents of Dimona had it rough, and we helped them. This was during the transitional immigrant camps. We gave them bread and milk and when it was muddy, we helped them get home on our camels. Where will we go now?” he asks angrily. “We helped Israel, and this is what we deserve? Even if the state comes in and throws a mass of explosives on us and kills us all, we won’t move. We will die here.”

As villagers were still processing the news, invitations were already circulating for the ceremony marking one year since the destruction of the village of Umm al-Hiran – a nearly identical case, even cited in the High Court’s ruling. Then, as now, the inequality is glaring: the evacuation of Bedouin who have lived on the land for generations, to make way for housing for Jewish residents, with no suitable alternative offered.

Some 500 people are slated to be evacuated from Ras Jrabah – residents the state itself recognized as “authorized” users of the land, whose presence there is documented from the Ottoman and British periods. The aim is to clear space for a new Jewish neighborhood planned for Dimona. The residents’ request to be included in the plans for the future neighborhood was not even reviewed.

Yet such an option did exist: the NGOs Bimkom and Adalah drafted detailed plans that would allow the community to be integrated into the city and formalize their presence on the site. The Authority for the Development and Settlement of the Bedouin in the Negev, however, rejected the proposal.

Sheikh Freij Alhwashla at a meeting in Ras Jrabah, November 2025. He has lived on this land long before Dimona was established

In the last two years, the Negev has seen a growing wave of evictions and demolitions of unrecognized villages. Still, many were surprised by the High Court’s decision regarding Ras Jrabah, given that the approval for “Dimona East” – the project ostensibly requiring the village’s evacuation – was canceled last July by the Be’er Sheva District Court. That court sent the plan back for revision, citing “severe defects,” including the failure to review the villagers’ request to be included as residents in the plan, a requirement set by previous rulings.

Some saw this decision as a legal victory, but before anyone even began reviewing the residents’ inclusion, the High Court ruling reshuffled the deck. The District Court’s June decision is mentioned only in passing by the High Court, whose justices emphasized that it had not been deliberated and referred the “issue” back to planning committees.

“The justices say, continue reviewing their inclusion during the planning process,” says attorney Myssana Morany of Adalah, who represents the villagers. “But who in the planning committee is going to speak to me when there is a High Court decision ordering the residents’ evacuation?”

An embedded mechanism of discrimination
The High Court’s ruling draws a clear line in state policy toward a community that has lived on its land since before the establishment of Israel, a policy that is often characterized by vagueness and bureaucratic delays.

In its decision, the Court sidestepped the core issue of the residents’ exclusion from the planning process for the new Dimona neighborhood. Instead, the justices focused on why the villagers should move to a designated Bedouin community, as the state argued. In doing so, the Court embraced the Israel Land Authority’s (ILA) position on safeguarding “public land,” while effectively upholding a system in which Bedouin villagers are excluded from that very public.

The insistence not to include the residents even as a possibility in any future planning reveals discriminatory policy disguised in professional terminology and promises of “developing the Negev.” Thus, while formally rejecting the villagers’ claims of discrimination, the High Court simultaneously exposes one of the deepest mechanisms shaping housing policy in the Negev since Israel’s founding.

On one hand, the justices ruled that establishing communities “solely for the Bedouin ethnic group” does not constitute segregation and is ostensibly intended “for their benefit.” On the other hand, they explicitly accepted the ILA’s regulation barring evicted Bedouin from receiving plots inside Jewish communities, limiting them instead to “Bedouin communities.” In effect, the Court elevated what had seemed like a narrow, technical regulation into a fundamental principle.

New construction in Dimona, seen from the village, November 2025

“In the end, this all rests on institutional separation between Jews and Bedouin in the Negev,” says attorney Morany. “The state did establish designated Bedouin communities, but refuses to consider other alternatives, even when dealing with long-standing villages on land zoned for housing, whose residents want to be integrated. The state claims its authority extends only to relocating villagers to Bedouin communities, and the Court goes so far as to frame this as a benefit – a claim hard to accept given the neglected condition of Bedouin communities today.”

In their ruling, the justices emphasized that evacuees are entitled to significant benefits – exemption from tender, subsidized plots and attainable housing – only if they relocate to a Bedouin community. Within the planned Dimona neighborhood – which, it must be stressed, is to be built on the villagers’ land – they may “purchase a plot like anyone else.” But this is not a realistic option: most villagers lack the financial means, and some are farmers with no alternative livelihood, whose future income will be severely impacted by forced relocation.

The villagers’ request to be exempted from tender within the new neighborhood, rather than in a designated Bedouin community, was the only practical option that would allow them to remain on the land where their families have lived since Ottoman times. The justices however, ruled that “the ordinances of the Land Authority do not recognize such a remedy.”

In other words, while the High Court insists the policy is not segregation, the ruling indicates that separation is inherent to the very mechanism of benefits; that is, that the policy itself produces segregation. According to the ordinance, benefits are granted to Bedouin only in Bedouin communities, while the ILA is prevented from regularizing their status within Jewish communities, even when those communities are built on their ancestral land.

“In fact, the Court rules here for the first time that the ILA ordinance can be interpreted in only one way: either you relocate to a Bedouin community, or you enter the tender. There are no other alternatives,” Morany explains. “In practice, this is segregation. You don’t have to explicitly say, ‘You can’t live here,’ to achieve that outcome. You just construct mechanisms and incentives that funnel members of a particular group into living only with others of that group – just like in the United States, where segregation persisted long after racist laws were abolished because people were denied home sales or mortgages in other neighborhoods. Now, the Court frames relocation to a Bedouin community as a ‘benefit,’ as if residents should be grateful that such communities exist.”

“Like a knife in the back”
Justice Yechiel Meir Kasher, who authored the leading opinion, wrote that the ILA had acted proportionally and offered the residents viable alternatives. These included relocation to the village of Qasr al-Sir, where evacuees would receive a plot of land at no cost and a grant of up to 250,000 shekels to build a home. Kasher also noted that although the expansion of Qasr al-Sir has not yet been completed, temporary housing solutions are available, with the ILA willing to assist residents with rent during the interim period.

According to the justice, villagers rejected the proposal because they insisted on remaining in their current village. The residents, however, argue that the lands in Qasr al-Sir are disputed, making it impossible to build housing there.

“They say there’s a solution and that we’re being difficult, but the problem isn’t with us,” explains Hassan Freij Alhwashla, 43, the sheikh’s son. “The land we’re being offered in Qasr al-Sir belongs to other people. It’s like being told to live in someone else’s house, while the owner stands there saying: this is my land. If we relocate there, we’ll end up in a dispute that could turn bloody. We’ve already received threats. So let the ILA sort this out, let them come up with a real solution.”

What Hassan describes is a well-known phenomenon in the Negev: because the state does not recognize Bedouin landownership claims, it frequently designates disputed land as a “solution” for resettling other Bedouin. This practice ignores the fact that the existing landholders oppose such relocation. These disputes make development and construction difficult across many parts of the Negev.

“It’s no coincidence that our case reached the High Court,” Hassan continues. “If there had been a real solution, do you think we would have gone through all of this? We proposed being integrated into the new neighborhood, or building a separate neighborhood for ourselves in Dimona – but no one even looked our way. (Dimona Mayor) Benny Bitton always says he’ll come meet us, but he never has. We’re not opposed to relocating away from this area. Just give us a real solution. We’re willing to move. We’re not looking for a fight.”

New construction in Dimona, seen from the village last week. Credit: Eliahu Hershkovitz
Hassan stands at the edge of the village. On one side lies a vast stretch of desert; on the other, a new villa neighborhood of Dimona. The contrast is glaring. Over there, children play soccer on a proper field; here, children roll barrels for entertainment. Over there, homes are solidly built and streets have modern lighting; here, residents live in sheet-metal structures powered by a buzzing generator. Even cell reception disappears once the paved road gives way to dirt.

Since the ruling, Hassan has barely slept or gone to work. He finds it hard to process what he calls “a knife in the back.” He speaks of his family’s loyalty to Israel – of people his age still serving in the reserves. “We are part of Israel, not its enemies,” he says, a phrase heard repeatedly in demolished villages, as well as in villages awaiting demolition.

For Hassan, the ruling is unmistakably discriminatory. “The land is approved for housing, so why won’t they settle the status of people who have lived here since before Israel existed? It’s only because we are Bedouin,” he says. “There is no justice here. What kind of democracy is this? I never imagined we’d be evicted without a solution.”

His voice cracks, frustration and rage visible in his eyes. “The first thing I thought of when I heard the ruling was my children,” he adds after a long pause, his voice low. “What will they think when they see bulldozers demolish their home? What will they think of the country they’re growing up in? No one is thinking about the next generation, about what these decisions mean, about what it means to witness such destruction. They keep pushing and pushing, and eventually it explodes.”

This article is reproduced in its entirety

© Copyright JFJFP 2026