Israel’s settlers can’t hide the brutal reality in the West Bank, just like they couldn’t hide Gaza


Efforts by Israeli right-wing pundits like Amit Segal and Gadi Taub to obscure the truth about settler violence against Palestinians in the West Bank reveal that the settlers are on the cusp of a legitimacy crisis. They have no one to blame but themselves Photojournalists and activists, left, document Israeli settlers who were attempting to disrupt the harvest of olive groves by Palestinian farmers in the West Bank town of Silwad, on 29 October 2025

Joshua Leifer writes in Haaretz on 29 October 2025:

The attacks of October 7 and Israel’s subsequent devastation of Gaza also ignited a lethal conflagration of settler violence in the occupied West Bank. Over the same two-year period that Israeli forces killed more than 68,000 Palestinians in Gaza, more than 1,000 Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank. New settler outposts have been constructed with rapid speed, displacing entire Palestinian communities – a process often facilitated by Israel’s army.

While the tenuous cease-fire in Gaza has allowed the besieged territory’s residents a small measure of relief, the settler attacks in the West Bank have not stopped. Each week brings harrowing testimonies and more images of gruesome brutality. Much like the humanitarian catastrophe that Israel wrought in Gaza, the settler pogroms in the West Bank are widely documented, often recorded on video, and viewed by millions around the world.

In the face of this reality, there appears to be a concerted campaign on the part of the pro-Israel right to deny it. In Tablet Magazine, the neoconservative pundit Gadi Taub published an article titled “The Settler Violence Myth,” in which he relies almost entirely on a report by the right-wing settler group Regavim to argue that the narrative of growing settler violence is a foreign NGO-funded conspiracy to force a two-state solution on Israel.

Amit Segal, the Channel 12 right-wing pundit and columnist for the Adelson-owned Israel Hayom, charged during a talk promoting his new book that Haaretz was “the number one threat on [sic] Israel’s position in the world,” singling out this paper’s coverage of human rights abuses in the West Bank. Haaretz, Segal claimed, presented a distorted picture in which “settler violence is more than Palestinian violence in the West Bank,” he said, “where the reality is that Palestinian violence is a thousand more times than settlers’ violence.”

Hilltop youth throwing rocks at Palestinians in the West Bank town of Turmus Ayya in June 2025

There is no evidence to support Segal’s claims. Far more Palestinians have been killed in recent years by Israeli soldiers and settlers than settlers by Palestinians – the numbers do not come close. The “thousand times” figure that Segal states is, as the U.S. president would say, fake news. The process of displacement by which settlements and outposts take new land, while Palestinians are forced from their homes can be seen, literally, on Google Maps.

Yet denials like those of Taub and Segal disclose the very truth they want to deny: The graphic, ubiquitous documentary evidence of rampant settler violence in the West Bank does, in fact, great harm to Israel’s image in the world. The settlers are responsible for incurring the wrath of global public opinion, not Haaretz. Reporters are not the ones setting Palestinians’ homes and cars ablaze, but the settlers themselves, whose political representatives often defend such acts in public, as if their Hebrew remarks cannot be translated.

Massive disappointment
There is also something almost quaint in the tacit assumption, shared by both Taub and Segal, that the reporting of conventional journalism outlets is the reason so many people outside of Israel have become aware of settler attacks on Palestinians. If anything, the opposite it is true.

Smartphones and video cameras can turn any witness to violence into a citizen journalist. Over the last two years, global social media feeds have been flooded with the images of Palestinian children in Gaza maimed by Israeli bombs, civilians burnt alive in the tents they pitched on the rubble of their destroyed homes – all in the almost total absence of foreign professional reporters.

Likewise, in the West Bank, many Palestinians are documenting attacks by settlers on their own – yes, sometimes with the help of Israeli human rights organizations and international activists – broadcasting their unmediated experiences to audiences worldwide.

What accounts for the push to discredit such testimony now? The reason is that the Trump administration has dealt a serious blow to the settler movement’s dreams of annexing the West Bank. And for figures like Segal in particular, this is a massive disappointment. Not long ago, Segal salivated at the possibility that Trump might give Netanyahu a green light on annexation. Those hopes have been dashed. Israel, Trump recently told Time Magazine, would “lose all its support” from the U.S. if it were to annex the West Bank.

In the immediate aftermath of October 7, the settler right felt that it entered a moment of divine opportunity. Orit Strock, a Knesset Member from the far-right Religious Zionism party, described the war that left more than 1,200 Israelis dead on its first day as “a period of miracles.”

It was this delusion of a cosmic opening that, in part, drove the settlers’ push to consolidate control over as much land as possible in the West Bank through a combination of new construction and the expulsion of Palestinian communities on land slated for Israeli settlements. But while the settlers’ land-grab has not stopped, the messianic horizon that they hailed two years ago has faded. Formal sovereignty over the West Bank is not coming any time soon.

The end of the war in Gaza has left the settler movement in its most precarious position in many decades. Its public representatives are deeply unpopular. In polls, the Religious Zionism party, led by Bezalel Smotrich, does not cross the electoral threshold. In recent days, Israeli media has been filled with testimony of hostages, returned from Hamas captivity, who describe in detail how Itamar Ben-Gvir’s inflammatory remarks prompted their captors to beat them brutally.

Masks are off
In the diplomatic arena, the Trump administration still appears keen on closing a normalization agreement between Israel and Saudi Arabia, which will almost certainly require an explicit commitment on Israel’s part to the creation of a Palestinian state. It is not the global left that has revived talk of the two-state solution, but the U.S. president, who so many on the Israeli right celebrated until recently as the second coming of the Persian king Cyrus.

There are two truths, then, that the settler movement and its allies seem to want to obscure. If the first is the brutal reality of rampant settler attacks on Palestinians in the West Bank, the second is that the settler movement is on the cusp of a legitimacy crisis. And for this they have no one to blame but themselves, certainly not the boogeyman of human rights NGOs or independent journalists.

The October 7 attacks will go down in history as a massive, bleeding rebuttal to the paradigm of perpetual occupation management that has been the official policy of successive right-wing governments. At the same time, polling suggests that most Israelis would accept a Palestinian state if included as part of a larger regional normalization agreement with Saudi Arabia.

The Israeli mainstream is tired of war, desperate for normalcy. Yet every video of settler violence, every deranged remark by their politicians, is a reminder that the settler movement does not, in fact, want normalcy, and is instead praying to ignite a “decisive,” cataclysmic war.

The attempt to mask the reality of settler violence, exemplified by the work of Segal and Taub, is not concerned, at its core, with Israel’s future, but with the future of the settlements. And as has long been the case, the right is willing to sacrifice the security of the state – to jeopardize all of Israel’s future – on the altar of the occupation. At this point, that is evident to most of the world.

This article is reproduced in its entirety

© Copyright JFJFP 2026