War on Gaza: Why Palestinians doubt western promises of an independent state


As Israel continues to exterminate the population of Gaza, recent talk in western capitals about Palestinian statehood feels like a blatant hoax

A demonstrator waves a Palestinian flag during a protest in London on 21 February 2024 (Henry Nicholls/AFP)

Fareed Taamallah reports in Middle East Eye 22 February 2024

As a number of western countries, including the United States, weigh their options for potentially recognising a Palestinian state, the Israeli government has publicly rejected any international attempt to impose a solution.

As Palestinians, we have suffered for decades from the Israeli occupation, theft of our lands, and killing and displacement of our people. Based on our long and bitter experience with the US and its allies, we have great doubts about the seriousness of their stated intentions.

Have western governments finally noticed the elephant in the room? Have they sincerely recognised the necessity of ending the occupation and injustice, or is this whole exercise little more than a palliative to absorb the anger of public opinion?

The recent statements by western governments about recognising a Palestinian state are very broad, with no clear timetable or practical measures to force Israel’s compliance.

Palestinians cannot go back to an endless process like Oslo, which yielded no tangible results – and Israel should not be given veto power over the establishment of a Palestinian state.

There are also many questions about the composition of our long-awaited state and its borders. Would it stand in accordance with UN Resolution 181, which delineated precise borders, or would it be based on the Trump-era “deal of the century”, which envisaged the creation of Palestinian bantustans and gave Israel a green light to annex much of the occupied West Bank?

The fate of Israel’s illegal settlements, inhabited by hundreds of thousands of settlers, is also unclear. Would they be removed? Would they become citizens of the new Palestinian state?

And where would the capital of the new Palestinian state be – in Jerusalem, which the US previously recognised as Israel’s capital? What about the right of return for millions of Palestinian refugees?

More

© Copyright JFJFP 2025