The October failures


October 8, 2023
JFJFP
In October 1973, and again in October 2023, Israel suffered a breakdown in political and military command. It could not have imagined that the Arabs were capable or courageous enough to launch such a daring attack.

Palestinians take control of an Israeli tank after crossing the border fence with Israel from Khan Yunis in the southern Gaza Strip on October 7, 2023. (Photo: Stringer/ APA Images) Palestinians take control of an Israeli tank after crossing the border fence with Israel from Khan Yunis in the southern Gaza Strip on October 7, 2023.

At the time of writing, Palestinian fighters from Gaza are in control of several Israeli settlements, mostly surrounding Gaza in the Naqab region. It has been close to sixteen hours, and still, the Israeli army and other security forces are scrambling to find the light switch, so to speak. In a combined military operation that included rocket attacks and a massive ground invasion, Palestinians from Gaza launched an unprecedented attack into 1948 Palestine, or “Israel.”

Israeli journalist Oded Ben-Ami, who broke the news about the surprise attack on October 6, 1973, was on the air today. He referred to today’s attack as a fog shock while referring to 1973 as the October 6 failure. Today, he said that we are now witnessing the October 7 failure. In both cases, all the systems that were supposed to prevent or at least warn of a surprise attack of such magnitude collapsed.

It has been more than ten hours, and Israelis in settlements throughout the Naqab and especially around Gaza are under siege, with Palestinian fighters in control and only a small Israeli military presence. What is perhaps even harder to grasp is that Palestinian fighters have entered and now control the Gaza Brigade headquarters of the IDF — this is where the brigade commander, a general, is stationed. Palestinians from Gaza are walking freely around a military base in disbelief by deserted Israeli tanks.Meanwhile, thousands of wounded are in Israeli hospitals in the region, with reports streaming in of over 200 Israelis dead from this attack. Palestinians in Gaza are reporting that they have scores of hostages.

Each year during the days and weeks leading up to October 6, the Israeli press publishes articles, stories, and, from time to time, a shown-for-the-first-time movie clip or testimony about the 1973 October War, also known as the Yom Kippur War. The surprise attack launched by the Egyptian and Syrian armies on Yom Kippur Day of 1973 was devastating not only for the Israeli military but also for the Israeli public. Now, five decades after the October 6 disaster, Palestinians have given Israelis another rude wake-up call.

I will never forget the day the 1973 war started. It was a sunny afternoon on Yom Kippur, and being a non-practicing Jewish home, we were not in synagogue or fasting. I was hanging out at a friend’s house when the news of war broke, and the sirens began. My friend’s father suggested I go home, which I did. My house was just a five-minute walk, but it felt eerie. We lived in a quiet community just up the hill from Route 1, which is the main highway between Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. It was a very quiet day because it was Yom Kippur, and there was no traffic or public transportation, and it felt strange to know that another war was taking place.

More …

© Copyright JFJFP 2026