The forgotten history of the Jewish, anti-Zionist left

When Anti-Zionism was Jewish

An election poster of the General Jewish Labour Bund, Kiev, 1918. Credit: YIVO

JVL Introduction

In an interview with In These Times Benjamin Balthaser talks about themes he has developed in an academic article “When Anti-Zionism Was Jewish”.

Here he talks about the colonial origins of modern Zionism, and the Jewish left’s quarrel with it at the time, on the grounds that it was a form of right-wing nationalism, fundamentally opposed to working-class internationalism, and a form of imperialism.

There was a decisive shift post-war, and the dominant narrative is that the Holocaust changed Jewish opinion and convinced Jews of Zionism’s necessity.

But there were alternatives, even then, argues Balthasar for whom the Soviet Union’s support for partition in 1947 was a decisive moment in the left’s shift on Zionism.

From today’s vantage point, with Jewish ethno-nationalism in the ascendant, this Jewish anti-Zionist political tradition, provides a rich cultural and political resource for future struggles.

Reproduced with Benjamin Balthaser’s permission

This article was originally published by In These Times on Mon 13 Jul 2020.

Read the original here.

© Copyright JFJFP 2017