Palestinian journalists protest at arbitrary arrests

April 2, 2012
Sarah Benton

Journalists protest outside court in Ramallah

Arrest of Journalist Shayeb, Musawa Demands to End Arbitrary Arrests


In light of the recent arrest of journalist Yousef Al Shayeb; Musawa* demands the immediate implementation of relevant provision of legislative and legal guarantees to end all cases of arbitrary arrests which severely impedes the rule of law and freedom of expression.

Freedom of the press and the freedom of expression constitute a basic pillar of a vibrant and pluralistic democracy. As the fourth pillar of democracy, it is the duty of the press and media to provide people with information and exposing defects and contradictions which impede the rights of citizens. According to the latest developments in the case of the journalist, Yousef Al Shayeb’s arrest, there is an urgent need for immediate actions to make substantial amendments to the provisions of relevant laws, especially the Press and Publications Law (1995) which severely impede the free flow of information within and to Palestine.

The Palestinian Basic Law guarantees freedom of the media, whereby the State is prohibited in engaging in practices which would constitute a breach of these freedoms. However, as a result of vague law texts, coupled with unclear sanctions, as well as the lack of enforcement of the Basic Law, such fundamental freedoms are frequently violated.

The imprisoned Al Shayeb have announced a hunger strike, demanding his constitutional right that guarantees freedom of opinion and expression, as well as freedom of the press and media, and to ensure protection of sources, which to this date is insufficient.

Musawa’s position is based on the contemporary penal policy that prevents the arrest and/or detention of any journalists. This demand emerges in compliance with the constitutional principles which are enshrined in the Basic Law. This policy is in line with the position of several Arab countries that have modified such procedures on freedom of media and press; particularly referring to Morocco and Egypt. This demand also corresponds with the mobilization of the Arab spring which demands and promotes freedom, justice, equality, participation, innovation, and dialogue within the press and media.

We; Musawa, hereby urge legislative, political, administrative, and judicial decision makers in Palestine to expedite the process of providing legislative and legal guarantees to end such cases of arbitrary arrest against people, such as Al Shayeb, who openly challenge and question the authorities. Taking action against the arrest of journalists enhances the rule of law and contributes to a state of justice, which ultimately prevents policies of unilateralism and hegemony.

[*”Musawa is an independent civil society NGO established on March 18th 2002 as part of an initiative by lawyers, former judges, and human rights advocates devoted to guaranteeing the independence of the judiciary and the legal profession through: monitoring and documenting violations; and treating the social, cultural, economic, and political obstacles that hinder the proper implementation of the independence of the judiciary and the legal profession.”]

What happens when a Palestinian journalist dares criticize the Palestinian Authority?

Palestinian journalist Yusuf Al-Shayeb dared raise suspicions of corruption at the PA’s mission in France. Now he languishes in a Ramallah cell.

By Amira Hass, Ha’aretz

Journalists who stood outside the court building exchanged jokes about the “six million dollars.” No problem, we’ll obtain them, someone said. That’s small change, another said. But these light remarks did not hide concerns about their colleague, Yusuf Al-Shayeb, who was at the time on his way to the Magistrate’s Court in Ramallah, to have his remand extended.

The Palestinian Authority’s foreign ministry, headed by Foreign Minister Riyad Al-Maliki, and the Palestinian diplomatic mission in France have submitted libel claims against Al-Shayeb – who works for the Palestinian Al-Ayyam newspaper (which is associated with the PA ) and AlGhad, a Jordanian newspaper – demanding compensation of six million dollars.

Of the two papers that he writes for, it was the Jordanian one that on January 29 published his report on claims of corruption at the Palestinian diplomatic mission in France. The report alleged that the mission’s deputy ambassador, Safwat Ibraghit, compels Palestinian students to spy on Muslim groups in France and relay information to Palestinian and foreign intelligence services. Al-Shayeb also claimed that Maliki, Palestinian National Fund director Dr. Ramzi Khouri, and Abu Nabil, who handles funds for Fatah, were responsible for Ibraghit’s promotion, despite complaints that have been leveled against him.

Al-Shayeb noted that sources in the PA foreign ministry reject these claims and brand them “malicious.” According to these sources, persons who level complaints against the diplomatic mission are acting out of personal interests and want to besmirch the reputation of senior officials who were nominated by the PA government and by the PLO. The sources also told Al-Shayeb that the Foreign Ministry does not hesitate to investigate complaints leveled against it.

Responses to the article that reinforced its allegations were posted immediately on the AlGhad website. One of the respondents noted that the diplomatic mission itself had not issued a statement to the media.

On January 31, Al-Shayeb was summoned to the PA’s general intelligence service’s office in Ramallah. He refused to reveal the identity of his sources, and said that under the 1995 Palestinian press and publications law, a journalist is obliged to reveal sources only under orders issued by a court.

Since he was not classified as a detained suspect, his phone was not confiscated and he was able to report about his whereabouts. Later, he told a reporter from the Doha Center for Media Freedom that while he was interrogated in the intelligence service offices, his cell phone received threatening messages.

The same day, incidentally, another journalist, Rami Samara, who works for the official Palestinian news service Wafa and for a local radio station, was arrested. The pretext for his detention was a mocking Facebook entry he posted that ridiculed the PLO’s decision to resume negotiations with Israel (talks which, as expected, were deferred ). The two journalists were released in the evening; before their release, the Palestinian Journalists Union in the West Bank staged a rally on their behalf at Ramallah’s Manara Square.

On February 20, Al-Shayeb was stunned to discover that his newspaper published an apology for his report. A few days later, he was fired. According the Doha Center for Media Freedom’s website, Al-Shayeb submitted an official complaint to the Jordanian journalists’ association, and also started legal proceedings against AlGhad. But he was not able to make much headway because he was detained last Sunday, March 25, on orders from the Palestinian attorney general; he was initially arrested for 48 hours. The journalists’ association protested this arrest, and arranged a protest vigil when he was taken for a remand extension last Wednesday.

The court compound is located across from the Foreign Ministry. On Wednesday morning, a few minutes before 10 A.M., there did not appear to be an unusual deployment of policemen and security personnel in this area. Slowly journalists and a few citizens who were stunned by this arrest started to stream toward the court. One person, who never even read the original, controversial report, said that she was distressed that a reporter could be arrested for doing his job. Another person noted that the arrest was carried out under the authority of the 1960 Jordanian penal code, which the Palestinian Authority has not altered, but the 1995 press and publication law protects the right of a journalist to maintain a source’s confidentiality.

While some 30 people demonstrated in the street, some colleagues of the detained journalist were in the courtroom, watching as the attorney general’s representative asked for a remand extension so that the suspect’s questioning could be continued. The allegation, in Al-Ayyam’s words, was that Al-Shayeb “published libelous rumors that damaged the reputation of official bodies which represent the Palestinian Authority.” Al-Shayeb was brought into the courtroom in handcuffs, accompanied by armed policemen.

One of his sources, Zuhair Al-Asali, who worked as a translator in the French mission, decided to reveal his identity. In a YouTube video he discusses information which he relayed to the journalist. None of this influenced the attorney general’s position and that of the judge.

Defense attorney Dawoud Dira’wi asked the court to release his client on bond until the trial date, but the judge, Fatoum E’beyat, decided to extend the remand by 15 days. Al-Shayeb declared that he is starting a hunger strike. On the same day, the court extended by 15 days the remand of Ismat Abd al Haleq, a woman who posted on Facebook some remarks about Abu Mazen’s children.

An associate in Ramallah told me that “the authorities’ behavior only reinforces the general feeling that all the claims which he [Al-Shayeb] raised were true. The arrest and the demand for compensation are designed to intimidate journalists and deter them from exposing corruption.”

In contrast, the foreign minister, while attending last Thursday the Arab Summit meeting in Baghdad, adamantly upheld the PA’s right to arrest Al-Shayeb. Speaking with the editor of the Maan news agency, Maliki angrily stated that the PA is the victim in this instance, and he called on Palestinian journalists to expunge Al-Shayeb from their roster.

“This is a dangerous precedent, and a dark day for journalism and journalists,” declared the West Bank journalists union, calling on all journalists to join its boycott of the “2012 freedom of journalism award,” about which no other than the Palestinian Authority issued an announcement last Tuesday.

© Copyright JFJFP 2022