There is no plan D

July 16, 2017
Sarah Benton

A premature baby depends on electricity to power the incubator and air conditioning  at Shifa hospital in Gaza City June 12, 2017. Photo by Mohammed Salem/ Reuters

Premature babies and sick children at risk from Gaza’s constant blackouts

Today, the territory’s power cuts are the worst in recent memory, with the strip going dark for longer stretches than it did in wartime

By Naomi Zeveloff, The National
July 16, 2017

In the neonatal intensive care unit at Al Shifa hospital in Gaza City, newborn babies lie in beeping plastic incubators as transparent tubes deliver oxygen and nutrients into their tiny bodies. Most of them were born prematurely, some weighing less than a bag of sugar with feet no bigger than dates.

These babies are the most vulnerable people in one of the most vulnerable places in the world, the Gaza Strip, a territory of two million that has been under Israeli siege for the past 10 years. Now, as Gaza sinks deeper into an electricity crisis — most households get four hours of electricity every 24 hours at latest count — these infants are at further risk. If the machines they are attached to lose power, they could lose their lives.

Al Shifa hospital uses generators as backup, but the system is not infallible. Any interruption in electricity will be a “catastrophe”, said Allam Abu Hameda, the doctor who oversees the neonatal intensive care unit, or NICU.

He had just finished checking on two infants lying on an open cot. It was a sweltering July day at the peak of a Middle Eastern heatwave, but the NICU was cool, one of the few rooms in the hospital where air conditioning is imperative for care.

Gaza’s blackouts are a humanitarian crisis caused by politics, part of the larger trend of “de-development” in the strip over the past 10 years of Israeli blockade and Hamas rule, as described by a United Nations report last week. In 2006, after Hamas kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit — who was later released in a prisoner swap — Israel bombed Gaza’s power plant. Though it was later repaired, it never again reached full capacity. Electrical lines from Egypt and Israel supply additional power to the strip, but not enough to meet demand. For around the past 10 years, Gaza has been on a severe schedule of eight hours with power followed by eight hours without.

Then in April, Gaza grew even dimmer after a Palestinian dispute over fuel tax closed down the power plant. Hamas, which runs the Gaza Strip, pays the West Bank-based Palestinian Authority to purchase fuel from Israel at a tax rate of around 100 per cent. When the PA refused Hamas’s request to reduce the taxes, the group stopped buying the fuel for the power plant. A recent shipment of fuel from Egypt provided temporary relief, but on July 12, the power plant shut down again.

Since April, the PA has been exerting pressure on Gaza with the aim of retaking control of the strip from Hamas, which ousted rival group Fatah and the PA in a bloody battle 10 years ago. As part of this effort, which also reportedly includes denying medical care to mortally ill Gazans who need to travel outside the strip, the PA asked Israel to cut electricity to Gaza. The Israeli security cabinet took up the issue and decided to incrementally reduce the power from around 120 megawatts to 80 megawatts, all but leaving Gaza in the dark.

Today, Gaza’s blackouts are the worst in recent memory, with the strip going dark for longer stretches than it did in wartime.

Hamas has warned that the electricity cuts could backfire on Israel if the pressure inside Gaza grows too great. “Hamas is not interested in an escalation” with Israel, Hamas spokesman Hazem Kassem told The National. “But the pressure, the stress due to the siege and [Palestinian president Mahmoud] Abbas’s actions against Gaza may push the people to explode against the one who is imposing the siege.”

Israel’s last war with Gaza, in 2014, devastated the coastal strip, killing more than 2,100 Palestinians, most of them civilians, and 72 Israelis, most of them soldiers. According to last week’s UN report, 171,000 homes were damaged or destroyed in the war.

The blackouts affect everyone. Without electricity to properly power the sewage treatment plants, untreated wastewater pours into the Mediterranean daily, poisoning the sea where Gazans swim. At home, food goes bad in non-functioning refrigerators. Gazans have had to adjust their shopping habits, buying only what they need for that day.

When the power does come, sometimes in the middle of the night, families rush to do laundry and charge mobile phones and batteries. Some neighbours have clubbed together to buy generators, each family paying to run a line to its home. Those who can afford it have installed solar panels but in many homes, candles or dim LED bulbs are the only light sources at night.

At Al Shifa hospital, the staff work around the clock to ensure there is no interruption in care in the most critical wards, such as the NICU and the kidney dialysis centre, while other wards manage with limited electricity or none. With electricity from the Gaza grid available for only a small part of the day, the hospital uses massive generators the size of army tanks to power the campus. UPS (uninterrupted power supply) devices ensure there is no lag in electricity between when the power goes off and the generators come on.



One of the electricity generators supporting Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City. Photo by William Parry/ Al Jazeera

“We are working under emergency conditions,” said Ashraf Al Qidra, the spokesman of the ministry of health in Gaza. The light and air conditioning stopped abruptly at one point in the interview and then started again.

“This happens in the hospitals. When there is overload, the generator stops,” he said. It is the patients who pay the price, he added.

In the NICU, for example, the machines do not always work properly with the constantly switching electricity sources. At least once a week, an incubator falters and reduces the oxygen flow to an infant, said Mr Abu Hameda. The staff on hand must be quick to notice the change in pressure and hand pump oxygen until the machine works properly again. He recalled an incident last week when a nurse rescued an infant who was losing oxygen. Thankfully, he said, the baby was unharmed and is now back with its parents.

“If one baby is missed it can be fatal,” he said.

At Al Rantissi Hospital, a children’s hospital in Gaza City, there was a full-blown emergency last month when for 10 minutes there was no power after the electricity shut off, said Muhammad Abu Selmya, the hospital director. Doctors and nurses rushed into the intensive care unit and began hand pumping oxygen to patients, using their cell phones to light the room until the generator power kicked in.

At the ministry of health, Mr Al Qidra said there was one clear answer to the crisis.

“We want Israel to lift the siege,” he said. “When there is no siege we will be able to give good health services and develop our health care system and our human resources and build more hospitals since we have more people now.”

Israel claims the blockade is crucial to its national security, to prevent Hamas from arming against Israel. But Gazans say the measure is collective punishment.

Mr Al Qidra called on the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia to step in to solve the electricity crisis in a sustainable way.

“I blame Hamas — they control the Gaza strip, they have to take care of it”

Some Gazans blame Hamas for the lack of electricity in the territory it controls.

Kemeleya Satary, a 33-year-old mother from Khan Younis in southern Gaza, is in no doubt.

“I blame Hamas — they control the Gaza strip, they have to take care of it,” she said. Her nine-year-old son Raafat needs dialysis four times a week. It means a 25-kilometre taxi journey from Khan Younis in the south of the Gaza strip to Al Rantissi hospital. Raafat’s older brother died from the same condition 11 years ago and without a kidney transplant, dialysis is his only hope of survival.

The power cuts make it difficult to care for Raafat at home. Without power, his mother cannot charge the battery to run the fan to keep him comfortable. Instead, she fans him with her hands, and asks her daughter to take over when she gets tired.

A high-ranking Hamas official in her area has a generator, and charges neighbours 160 shekels (Dh165) a month to hook up to it, Ms Satary said. She occasionally plugs in, such as when she needed to cook the iftar meal during Ramadan. She wondered why Hamas could not set up such machines for the public.

One of Mr Dahlan’s real tests will be whether he can help turn back the power on permanently

Ms Satary and many others in Gaza saw hope in Mohammad Dahlan, the former Fatah leader in the territory who grew up in Khan Younis. Once an enemy of Hamas, Mr Dahlan is now making overtures to the group, and many in Gaza speculate that he could come back to rule the strip. According to Hamas spokesman Mr Kassem, Mr Dahlan is engaging in a process of “social reconciliation” with Hamas in order to compensate families who lost loved ones or property in the 2007 Battle of Gaza when Hamas ousted Fatah and the PA from the strip.

One of Mr Dahlan’s real tests will be whether he can help turn back the power on — and not just temporarily. So far, the solution has eluded Gaza’s leaders.

“You know we have a problem when the government increases the power from three hours to six hours and calls it a victory,” said Ms Satary, as she left the dialysis centre. “It should be on 24 hours.”

Meanwhile at Gaza’s hospitals, the backup plan is now the standard operating procedure. Generator power was supposed to be “Plan B”, said Mr Abu Selmya of Al Rantissi, not for every day use.

Now he also has a “Plan C”, a smaller generator to fall back on in case the big ones fail.

“Don’t ask about ‘Plan D’,” he said. “There is no ‘Plan D’.”

Muhammad Dahman stands near the solar energy panels he installed on his roof in Gaza City. Photo by Naomi Zeveloff for The National

How solar power is helping Gaza residents overcome electricity crisis

Most Gazans can’t afford solar energy, but for upper and middle class people in the embattled strip it is becoming an increasingly popular option as the local energy system crumbles

By Naomi Zeveloff, The National
July 15, 2017

With two sons at university, a third son in high school, and another daughter coming up through the Gaza school system, Muhammad Dahman’s children study day and night, using lights to read and fans to cool off in the heat of Gaza City.

Though Mr Dahman, a 46-year-old journalist, is proud of his children, their study routine was once a source of anxiety. In Gaza, where electricity is at a premium, more homework meant more money. On top of the 200 shekels, (Dh206) he paid per month to connect to Gaza’s weak power grid, he shelled out at least another 200 shekels per month for a generator, just to keep the lights on at night.

In April, when the Gaza Strip power plant ran out of fuel following a dispute between Hamas, which rules Gaza, and the Palestinian Authority, which governs the West Bank, Mr Dahman decided that enough was enough. On a friend’s advice, he invested in solar energy. In May, he spent about Dh7,350 [about the same in £sterling] — which he is still paying off — on four shiny solar panels on the roof, next to his nephew’s pigeon coop.

The panels provide the electricity Mr Dahman’s family uses during the day, and also charges the batteries that they use at night. Now, he says, the family has a “new life”. Not only does he have enough electricity to meet all their needs, his home has become a hangout for cousins wanting to cool off or charge their mobile phones.

Sitting in his fan-cooled living room, Mr Dahman said it was a relief to no longer depend on the Gaza Strip grid. Today, he believes that solar energy is the way of the future for the territory. The fact that solar energy is better for the environment is of secondary concern to him. “I just want light!” he said.

Most Gazans can’t afford solar energy, but for upper and middle class people in the embattled strip it is becoming an increasingly popular option as the local energy system crumbles. The United Nations Development Programme is also installing solar panels in schools and hospitals in Gaza. Last month, the Israeli government further reduced its energy supply to the territory at the behest of the Palestinian Authority, which blamed Hamas for failing to repay the energy costs. Now, Gazans are receiving just four hours of electricity every 24 hours.

Not far from Mr Dahman’s home on a busy Gaza City thoroughfare, a solar company has put shimmering panels on display on the pavement outside its shop. Inside, Tareq Darwish, the Oceanic Company’s 25-year-old accountant, says that sales of the India-made panels, which must pass through Israel to reach Gaza, have almost tripled in the last 10 weeks. From selling 15 panels a month, they are now selling up to 50. With more vendors selling the panels, prices have gone down from 1,000 shekels per panel to 600 or 700 shekels [about £150].

It’s still not cheap — Mr Darwish says he can’t even afford the product he is selling — but he tells customers that solar panels are a safe and environmentally friendly alternative to generators, which can be deadly if misused. In the past, Gazans have died from generator fires and carbon monoxide poisoning from keeping their units indoors.

Business owners in Gaza are also looking to solar energy. In the northern part of Gaza City, the tall metal roof of the Al Nour Gas station is topped by tilted solar panels drinking up the sun. The petrol station is part of a large complex owned by the Abu Qamer family, which also includes a popular 24-hour grocery store known all over the northern Gaza Strip for its large refrigerators full of perishable items such as hummus and labane cheese, and a 12-unit apartment building housing more than 100 members of the family.

Family patriarch Fateh Abu Qamer, now in his 60s, invested US$52,000 (Dh191,000) in 90 solar panels and 30 batteries to power the complex last July. In the past, the two businesses would barely bring in enough money to cover the costs of electricity, he said. But he expects to make back what he spent on the solar panels and batteries in two years.

Others in the area have taken note and one of Mr Qamer’s neighbours has already followed suit. Mr Qamer welcomes neighbours who need to charge their mobile phones and even hooked up one neighbour’s electric-powered water supply, he said. In the Gaza heat, the Abu Qamer grocery store is a welcome oasis of cool in the locality.

“The most important thing is to keep the services running,” Mr Qamer added.

In Gaza today, that is no small feat.

© Copyright JFJFP 2017