Resisting the war against memory


October 2, 2012
Sarah Benton


See 2nd item: Thousands of people take part in a rally in the northern Arab town of Sakhnin inside the Green Line on 1 October 2012, to mark the 12th anniversary of the October 2000 massacre in which Israeli forces shot dead 13 Israeli Palestinians. Photo: AFP – Ahmad Gharabli


Video: Tel Aviv exhibit features testimony by Nakba perpetrators
By Charlotte Silver, Electronic Intifada
October 02, 2012

On 2 October in Tel Aviv, the Israeli organization Zochrot will open its exhibit Towards a Common Archive, a showing that features more than thirty testimonies by Zionist perpetrators of the 1948 Nakba.

Filmmaker Eyal Sivan and historian Ilan Pappe are curating the exhibit in conjunction with Zochrot, the only Israeli organization dedicated to remembering the expulsions and massacres in Palestine in 1948.

According to Zochrot’s website, the testimonies have been collected from interviews filmed specifically for this exhibit, in addition to “clips from documentaries by Israeli filmmakers with fighters’ testimonies, Nakba representations from feature films which constitute testimonies in their own right, [and] testimonies by second- and third-generation descendants of fighters.”

Also screening at the exhibit will be a preview of the online “Common Archive for 1948 Palestine” project, an additional undertaking led by Sivan.

Sivan’s latter project was announced last year and has the increasingly urgent ambition to collect testimonies from the aging generation of the Haganah, Palmach, Irgun and Stern Gang — those Zionist militias that perpetrated the crimes that are today known collectively as the Nakba.

“I killed someone”

The testimony [in this video] was given by Hava Keller, who enlisted in the Haganah in 1948 when she was a young teen. In her testimony, Keller describes how she oversaw the expulsion of Acre and how she thought the fleeing villagers would return.

Keller also describes when she killed someone,

“One of my worst memories was during the attack on Yehiam. And I killed someone. It was war and I acted exactly according to instructions. I waited until they arrived near the fence, then I shot and had tremendous luck, as he was killed on the spot. I think now, how would I have felt had he lay below my post for a few hours and screamed” (9:30).

Zochrot’s website features an excerpt from one of the filmed testimonies that will appear in the exhibit. A fighter in the Palmach-Yiftach brigade describes the Dahmash Mosque Massacre in Lydd, one of a series of expulsions and exterminations that together constitute the Nakba:

“They found a little hole, 120 people snuffed it. One hundred and twenty people were in this mosque. This I knew. They talked about it. They fled to the mosque because they thought that was the safest place – that there they wouldn’t kill them. Because they knew Israelis would not destroy a mosque.” (sic)

In writing about the project, Sivan emphasizes that while the last decade has seen the significant emergence of Palestinian testimonies of the Nakba, those of the perpetrators themselves are missing. And with a Truth and Justice Committee unlikely to be established in the near or immediate future, recording these testimonies now is imperative to any effort to save truth and memory.

The Common Archive aims “to create an audio-visual online archive of Jewish executor’s testimonies of the 1948 crimes with cross references to testimonies of Palestinian refugees and other historical visual data (maps, photos, etc).”

Eyal Sivan’s project draws on the writing and words of Primo Levi, who in his meticulous documentation and recollection of his time in Nazi concentration camps resisted what he called the “war against memory” waged by the Third Reich. (The Drowned and the Saved, 1986)

Likewise, the State of Israel has aspired to erase the memory of the Nakba for its victims, what Ilan Pappe called “memoricide” in The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine. Despite the Jewish National Fund’s feverish planting of trees over the remains of emptied villages and —more recently — the Knesset (Israel’s parliament) and Israeli high court’s desperate attack on any commemoration of the state’s founding crime, the memory persists.

Sivan credits Levi with making a distinction between the witness and the survivor, a distinction that Sivan applies to remembering the Palestinian Nakba: “The primary witness of any war crime is the perpetrator himself or herself. Perpetrator’s testimonies reveal the actions they committed, and the reasons they provided — or still provide — as a vindication of their criminal behavior,” he writes on the project’s description.

Sivan, an Israeli filmmaker who resettled in Paris in 1985, has made several documentaries about Palestine. His latest film, Jaffa, the Orange’s Clockwork (2009) examines the appropriation of Palestine’s fabled, luscious citrus fruits in Zionist discourse.


Palestinians inside the Green Line mark 12th anniversary of Intifada killings

Thousands of people take part in a rally in the northern Arab town of Sakhnin inside the Green Line on 1 October 2012, to mark the 12th anniversary of the October 2000 massacre in which Israeli forces shot dead 13 Palestinians.

By Al Akhbar
October 01, 2012

Palestinians living inside the Green Line on Monday called for justice over the killing of 13 civilians by Israeli forces in 2000 on the 12th anniversary of the massacre.

At least 2,000 marched in the Galilee town of Sakhnin, carrying Palestinian flags and pictures of the 13 killed in October 2000 during the Second Palestinian Intifada which had just begun, an AFP journalist at the scene reported.

Rallies were also held in Umm el-Fahm, Nazareth, Kfar Kana and other Palestinian villages in the Galilee.

“Twelve years have passed and as far as we are concerned it is as if the incident happened yesterday,” a spokesman for the families of the victims Ibrahim Siam said, the Israeli daily Haaretz reported.

Demonstrators chanted slogans and demanded that those responsible for the killings be indicted.

The Orr Commission, established following the deaths, found Israeli police incompetence and a history of discrimination against Palestinians living under Israeli rule.

Rights group Adalah represented the families of the victims before an official commission of inquiry, but in 2008 the attorney general issued a decision not to indict any of the Israeli police officers responsible for the deaths.

The killings took place during a series of Palestinian protests in the northern parts of Israeli-controlled territory at the onset of the Second Intifada cultivated by decades of Israeli repression of Palestinians.

The uprising was triggered when [Likud party leader] Ariel Sharon visited the holy Temple Mount and al-Aqsa Mosque which was taken as a provocation.

Around 20 percent, or 1.3 million people, of the population residing inside the Green Line are Palestinian.

They are largely the descendants of Palestinians that managed to remain during the 1948 war, when an estimated 700,000 were expelled from or fled their homes during fighting that would see the establishment of the state of Israel.

Rights groups say that Palestinians living under Israeli rule face discrimination in employment, education and public funding.

The Israeli government estimates that just over 50 percent of 1948 Palestinian families live under the poverty line.

Report from Ma’an, Al-Akhbar, AFP

© Copyright JFJFP 2017