Website policy


We provide links to articles we think will be of interest to our supporters. We are sympathetic to much of the content of what we post, but not to everything. The fact that something has been linked to here does not necessarily mean that we endorse the views expressed in it.
_____________________

BSST

BSST is the leading charity focusing on small-scale grass roots cross community, anti poverty and humanitarian projects in Israel/Palestine
____________________

JfJfP comments


2016:

06 May: Tair Kaminer starts her fifth spell in gaol. Send messages of support via Reuven Kaminer

04 May: Against the resort to denigration of Israel’s critics

2015:

23 Dec: JfJfP policy statement on BDS

14 Nov: Letter to the Guardian about the Board of Deputies

11 Nov: UK ban on visiting Palestinian mental health workers

20 Oct: letter in the Guardian

13 Sep: Rosh Hashanah greetings

21 Aug: JfJfP on Jeremy Corbyn

29 July: Letter to Evening Standard about its shoddy reporting

24 April: Letter to FIFA about Israeli football

15 April: Letter re Ed Miliband and Israel

11 Jan: Letter to the Guardian in response to Jonathan Freedland on Charlie Hebdo

2014:

15 Dec: Chanukah: Celebrating the miracle of holy oil not military power

1 Dec: Executive statement on bill to make Israel the nation state of the Jewish people

25 Nov: Submission to All-Party Parliamentary Group Against Antisemitism

7 Sept: JfJfP Executive statement on Antisemitism

3 Aug: Urgent disclaimer

19 June Statement on the three kidnapped teenagers

25 April: Exec statement on Yarmouk

28 Mar: EJJP letter in support of Dutch pension fund PGGM's decision to divest from Israeli banks

24 Jan: Support for Riba resolution

16 Jan: EJJP lobbies EU in support of the EU Commission Guidelines, Aug 2013–Jan 2014

2013:

29 November: JfJfP, with many others, signs a "UK must protest at Bedouin expulsion" letter

November: Press release, letter to the Times and advert in the Independent on the Prawer Plan

September: Briefing note and leaflet on the Prawer Plan

September: JfJfP/EJJP on the EU guidelines with regard to Israel

14th June: JfJfP joins other organisations in protest to BBC

2nd June: A light unto nations? - a leaflet for distribution at the "Closer to Israel" rally in London

24 Jan: Letter re the 1923 San Remo convention

18 Jan: In Support of Bab al-Shams

17 Jan: Letter to Camden New Journal about Veolia

11 Jan: JfJfP supports public letter to President Obama

Comments in 2012 and 2011

_____________________

Posts

Is criticism of Israel antisemitic?

Page last updated 25 Oct 2015

Introduction

“Beware of antisemitism, and all other forms of racism, but beware also of being cowed into silence by those who seek to stifle criticism of the oppressive politics of Israel by labeling you antisemitic.”

Archbishop Tutu to the Deutscher Evangelicher Kirche, 30 Apr 2015

Criticism of Israel can be antisemitic. It generally isn’t.

No more damage has been done to the struggle against antisemitism – a noxious, vicious form of racism – than by the hasbara (propaganda) industry with its suggestion that much/most/all criticism of Israel is antisemitic, or is likely, to foster antisemitism.

The critique takes many forms, including an attempt to write criticism of Israel into the very definition of antisemitism (e.g. in the so-called “working definition of antisemitism” of  2005, the story of which is a discrete chapter in the history of hasbara).

What we try to do in this section is to focus more on the arguments which suggest there is a “new antisemitism” abroad, with Israel as its target. This was clearly expressed by Natan Sharansky when he wrote in 2004 in his 3D Test of Anti-Semitism: Demonization, Double Standards, Delegitimization: “Whereas classical anti-Semitism is aimed at the Jewish people or the Jewish religion, ‘new anti-Semitism’ is aimed at the Jewish state”.

The idea is that Israel is singled out for unfair criticism, demonised and delegitimised, held up to standards from which others are exempt. This argument has a superficial plausibility as language around the conflict is often intemperate (on both sides it must be said, with supporters of Israel often quick to draw the accusation of antisemitism out of its holster). It attempts to normalise the assumption that criticism of Israel is likely to be antisemitic, “in effect if not in intent”. The result of this is to put the onus on critics of Israel to prove that they are not being antisemitic.  It has been used, particularly on US campuses, with considerable effect, to suppress debate about the Israel-Palestine conflict but its effects are also felt in Britain and elsewhere.

Criticism – harsh, hostile and sometimes making vastly exaggerated claims and unfounded allegations – abounds in political life. We might wish it didn’t, but at what point does or should it become illegitimate, be ruled out of court – or even made illegal? That’s what often is at stake in debates on this issue.

The notion of a “new antisemitism”  is central to the discussion about defining and understanding antisemitism today. We have located this discussion firmly in the section on Jewish identity since this notion makes support for Israel a central component of what it is to be Jewish today.

Central to the attack over recent decades has been the notion that Israel is unfairly picked on. General arguments about this are dealt with in a singling-out-Israel section. In more recent years the claim has become that Israel is now being demonised by being called an apartheid state. And the argument, heard more and more strongly as the BDS campaign chalks up its modest successes, is that this is the form that antisemitism is taking today.

Material on these themes can be found in these sections

Antisemitism in general
Singling out Israel
Is Israel an apartheid state?
BDS and antisemitism?

 


Contents of this section

9. SOME KEY DEBATES

a) Setting the scene: the hasbara (propaganda) war
b) Is criticism of Israel antisemitic?

Singling out Israel
Is Israel an apartheid society?
BDS and antisemitism

c) Can you have a Jewish and democratic state?
d) What is Zionism today?

e) The nature of the nakba
f) One state or two?
g) Is Hamas to blame? Is Gaza still occupied?
h) Right of return and law of return
i) The role of the JNF

 

Print Friendly